Murphy v. Borland
Murphy v. Borland
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court, November 17th 1879.
The right of Margaret McClurg to distrain for her dower was settled in a former action of replevin between the same parties : Borland v. Murphy, 4 W. N. C. 472. The doubt expressed in the per curiam opinion was perhaps personal to the writer, and must'not be accepted as interfering in any degree with the stability of that decision.
While there are several assignments of error there is really but one question. The distress was for the sum of $625, being the dower for one quarter, chargeable upon this particular property, and was made upon the goods of a tenant of a portion of the premises, who rented from the devisees of Alexander McClurg for $1500 per annum. It was claimed by the plaintiff that Mrs. McClurg was only entitled to distrain upon his goods for the amount of rent he was to pay his landlord. On the other hand the defendant contended that it was immaterial what amount of rent, or whether any rent was due from the plaintiff Borland, to the devisees of Alexander McClurg at the time Mrs. McClurg distrained his goods for her arrears of dower. This is the substance of the defendant’s first point (see 5th assignment), and was answered by the court as follows: “ The effect óf this point is to rule that if Mr. Borland’s rent was $375 a quarter, and the amount due Mrs. McClurg $625 a quarter, that, notwithstanding the agreement on' the part of Mr. Borland to pay $375, he could be levied on every quarter
The evidence referred to in the first and third assignments was improperly received. The terms of Borland’s tenancy did not in any manner interest or affect Mrs. McClurg; and the proceedings on the appointment of a receiver on her application were equally irrelevant. It would have been competent t'o show payment of the particular dower-money embraced in this suit, but that was not attempted.
None of the other assignments requires discussion.
Judgment reversed, and a venire facias de novo awarded.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Murphy versus Borland
- Status
- Published