Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1884

Mitchell v. Newman

Mitchell v. Newman
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided February 25, 1884 · Clark, Gordon, Green, Mercur, Paxson, Sterrett, Trunkey
4 Pennyp. 443

Mitchell v. Newman

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam :

This agreement of submission contains something more than a mere submission. It further stipulates that the defendant in error should give to the plaintiff in error possession of the books and papers of the firm, and that the latter should become the liquidating partner, with full power to dispose of its assets and pay its indebtedness therewith. This was a sufficient consideration to make the submission irrevocable -when made. An attempted revocation just as the award is about to be announced, and when there is persuasive evidence that the party had substantial knowledge of the conclusion at which the referees had arrived, is not entitled to much favor. It cannot be asserted except under a clear claim of right. Such right did not exist in this case.

Judgment affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.