Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1887

Sharp v. Wike

Sharp v. Wike
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided May 16, 1887 · No. 65 · Gobdon, Greek, Mekcub, Pee, Steebett, Tbunkky
6 Sadler 565; 9 A. 454; 1887 Pa. LEXIS 670

Counsel

P. II. Beinhard for plaintiffs in error., J. G. Adams and J. P. S. Gohin for defendants in error.

Sharp v. Wike

Opinion of the Court

Pee Curiam:

Two successive grand juries did recommend the erection of a neAV jail, and the recommendation was approved by the court of quarter sessions. The fact that the first grand jury proceeded further to direct the county commissioners to purchase a more desirable location at a price specified does not defeat the main recommendation, for two reasons: the one is that it is distinct matter which may be separated from the former; the other is that it is an attempt to restrict the discretionary power of county commissioners as to the specific location, which is not warranted by the statute. It-may, therefore, be treated as surplusage. It -follows that judgment was correctly entered in favor of defend.ants.

Judgment affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.