House of Refuge v. Smith
House of Refuge v. Smith
Opinion of the Court
Opision,
The question in this case is mainly one of definition. What .is the House of Refuge ? An examination of the several acts of assembly relating to it makes it very- clear that it is not merely a house with the necessary curtilage appurtenant to it, but a philanthropic establishment, an institution organized and maintained for the reformation of juvenile delinquents. Experience has shown that this work can ordinarily be better accomplished by giving to the unfortunate children suitable occupation of mind and body than by confinement in idleness. Such training of mind and muscle as is calculated to prepare the individual for self-support, is therefore part of the reformatory process. The work-shop, the schoolhouse, the garden, and the field, are therefore as truly a part of the plant as the place of detention itself.
What was said in Northampton Co. v. Lafayette College, 128 Pa. 132, may, with a slight modification, be applied to this case. The House of Refuge, looked at with reference to its reformatory work, consists of the superintendents, inmates, teachers, and keepers; but, viewed with reference to its prop
The learned judge of the court below was misled by a supposed analogy between this case and that of Wagner Free Inst. v. Philadelphia, 116 Pa. 555 [s. c. 182 Pa. 612]. In that case, the institute owned a building in which its library and cabinet were kept, and which was devoted to the proper work of the institute. This building was exempt from taxation. It had other real estate in the hands of tenants, producing rent
The decree of the court below is reversed and set aside, and the injunction prayed is awarded; the costs of this appeal to be paid by the appellee.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HOUSE OF REFUGE v. G. W. SMITH
- Cited By
- 20 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- (a) The House of Refuge of Philadelphia was incorporated by the act of March 23, 1826, P. L. 133, for the purpose of establishing and conducting an institution for the confinement and reformation of youthful delinquents, and was conceded to be an institution of purely public charity. (5) Under the authority of the act of May 13, 1889, P. L. 209, the managers purchased 884 acres of land in Delaware county, and removed the male dopartmentthereto. Said land is cultivated by inmates, to tlio end that they may be trained to agricultural labor; and the sale of the products of the farm defrays a part of the expenses of the institution: 1. The land so used is not income-producing in any proper sense; and being in the actual use of the managers and devoted absolutely to the purposes of the institution, as a part of the plant on and by means of which its reformatory work is carried on, it is exempt from taxation, under the act of May 14, 1874, P. L. 158: Wagner Institute’s App., 116 Pa. 555, distinguished.