Commonwealth v. Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Co.
Cases that cite this one
18 later published cases cite this decision.
- Commonwealth v. Twitchell (Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas 1963)
- Illinois Central Railroad v. City of Paducah (Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) 1929)
- Long v. Rockwood (Supreme Court of the United States 1928)
- Ferndale S. Dist. v. Conemaugh S. Dist. (Pa. 1937)
- Commonwealth v. Schuylkill Trust Co. (Pa. 1937)
- Ferndale Borough School District v. Conemaugh Township School District (Pa. 1937)
- Commonwealth v. Paul W. Bounds Co. (Pa. 1934)
- Lyntkowski v. Gallo (Pa. 1932)
- McMullin's Estate (Pa. 1922)
- New York & Pennsylvania Co. v. New York Central R. R. (Pa. 1920)
- Commonwealth v. McGlinn Distilling Co. (Pa. 1919)
- Perkins ex rel. Bank of Commerce v. Halpren (Pa. 1917)
- Fleer v. Reagan (Pa. Super. Ct. 1904)
- People ex rel. Edison Electric Illuminating Co. v. Harkness (New York Supreme Court 1895)
- Commonwealth v. Fall Brook Coal Co. (Pa. 1893)
- Commonwealth v. Pottsville Iron & Steel Co. (Pa. 1893)
- Commonwealth v. Philadelphia Co. (Pa. 1893)
- Commonwealth v. Edison Electric Light Co. (Pa. 1893)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
in No. 17 May T., 1892.
This cause was submitted to the decision of the court below without a jury under the act of 1874. In such cases it has
The sixth specification of error raises the question whether the defendant corporation is within the proviso to the twenty-first section of the act of June 1, 1889, P. L. 431, exempting the capital stock of corporations, limited partnerships and joint stock associations organized exclusively for manufacturing purposes and actually carrying on manufacturing within this state from taxation. The learned judge of the common pleas found that the company was incorporated by and in virtue of an act of the general assembly of this commonwealth approved April 9, 1872, entitled “An act to incorporate the Chartiers Improvement Company, and to define the powers thereof,” which referred to another act entitled “An act to incorporate the Improvement and Co-operative Company, with powers to acquire and improve property, to use and dispose of the same, and for other purposes,” approved May 12, 1871, for a definition of its powers, and made these acts part of his finding. Turning to the acts in question it is fouzid that the defendant corporation was empowered to engage in enterprises so vaguely defined that it would be unsafe to say what was not authorized, if anything could be authorized by such generalities, except the issue of its own obligations as currency which was expressly excluded, and manufacturing which the most liberal construction of the language of the act of 1871 would not comprehend. It was, however, expressly authorized “ to make purchases and sales of and investments in the securities of other companies,” and to do many other enumerated things which were not manufacturing. He farther found that during the tax fear 1890, and for some time previous thereto the defend- ' ant Was exclusively engaged in the manufacture of electrical apparatus and appliances and machinery for the generation,
But while the defendant is not within the proviso it does not follow that it is taxable upon its entire capital. Part of its capital is invested in patent rights, and that it is not taxable upon that part is so clearly and forcibly shown by the learned court below as to render further discussion of that subject undesirable. It is equally clear that it is not taxable upon another part invested in manufacturing plants situated in New York and New Jersey. This, however, is not controverted. But in addition to the items upon which tax was imposed by the judgment of the court below it is taxable upon so much of its tangible property as is situated in this commonwealth.
The judgment is reversed and judgment is now entered in faVor of the plaintiff for the sum of six thousand six hundred and sixty-one dollars and eighty-nine cents with costs.
October 3, 1892, in No. 1.5 May T., 1892:
The judgment is affirmed upon the opinion of the learned judge of the court below.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.