Com. ex rel. Greene v. Gregg
Cases that cite this one
30 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Hospital & Healthsystem Ass'n of Pennsylvania v. Department of Public Welfare (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2003)
- Turnbull v. Fink (Del. 1995)
- Hospital & Healthsystem Ass'n v. Department of Public Welfare (Pa. 2005)
- Biles v. Commonwealth (Pa. Commw. Ct. 1979)
- People v. Márquez Carrión (Supreme Court of Puerto Rico 1943)
- El Pueblo de Puerto Rico v. Márquez Carrión (Supreme Court of Puerto Rico 1943)
- Planned Parenthood of St. Louis Region v. Department of Social Services, Division of Medical Services (Mo. 2020)
- Planned Parenthood of St. Louis Region v. Department of Social Services, Division of Medical Services (Mo. 2020)
- Joseph B. Scarnati, Senator and President pro tempore of the Senate of PA v. Tom Wolf, Governor of PA (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2015)
- Constitutional Defense League v. Waters (Pa. 1932)
- State ex rel. Jones v. Clausen (Wash. 1914)
- City of Philadelphia v. Commonwealth (Pa. 2003)
- Adams County v. Commonwealth, Department of Public Welfare (Pa. 1983)
- Ortiz Reyes v. MacLeod (Supreme Court of Puerto Rico 1940)
- Caldwell v. Board of Regents of University of Arizona (Ariz. 1939)
- Calmenson Clothing Co. v. Kruger (S.D. 1938)
- Sellers v. Frohmiller (Ariz. 1933)
- Krasner, L., Aplt. v. Senator Kim Ward (Pa. 2024)
- Krasner, L. v. Ward, K.; Apl. of: Bonner (Pa. 2024)
- Krasner, L. v. Sen. Kim Ward; Appeal of Ward (Pa. 2024)
- Allegheny Reproductive Health Center v. PA DHS (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2020)
- Commonwealth v. Sloan (Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas 1971)
- Burke v. Clark (Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas 1952)
- State Ex Rel. Hueller v. Thompson (Mo. 1926)
- Piccirilli Bros. v. Lewis, Aud. Gen. (Pa. 1925)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The sole question presented is whether the item of the general appropriation bill of 1893, appropriating a sum “for the payment of the salary of a clerk in the offices of the prothonotaries of the Supreme Court,” etc., is a valid authority to the auditor general and state treasurer to issue and pay warrants for that purpose. The learned court below held that as the compensation of the prothonotary is fixed by the acts of Feb. 22, 1821, and April 2,1868, and no new duties are imposed by the present act, it was a mere gratuity and in violation of the constitution. In so holding, however, the learned court was careful to say that it had “ no doubt that the legislature could legally create the office of clerk to the prothonotary of the Supreme Court and provide for his compensation by a salary, just as they could by law increase the fees or compensation of the prothonotary himself, but in either case this would have to be done by a separate act.” This position is also conceded by the appellees in the argument of the present case.
It is uncontroverted therefore that the legislature could do the substantial thing, and the only question is whether it could do it in the present form. In general it will not be disputed that the legislature is the exclusive judge of the form in which its enactments shall be put, and its mandate in that respect cannot be questioned unless it transgresses a plain prohibition in the constitution. The only provision invoked here is section 15 of article 3, “ the general appropriation bill shall embrace nothing but appropriations for the ordinary expenses of the executive, legislative and judicial departments of the commonwealth,” etc. The history and purpose of that section are well known. It was aimed at the objectionable practice of putting a measure of doubtful strength on its own merits, into the general appropriation bill, in legislative phrase tacking it on as a rider, in order to compel members to vote for it or bring the
It cannot be assumed that the constitution meant to compel the legislature even to supervise all the details of the government. That is properly the function of the executive and judicial branches. What work there is to be done, and what clerical force is requisite to do it, is a question of detail as to which much must necessarily be left to the. head of each department. It is clearly the legislative province to keep a general control over the expenditure of the public funds, but this it does so long as no money is paid out without a previous appropriation for that purpose. While it thus holds the purse strings it controls the whole subject as completely as its proper functions under the constitution demand. In passing general appropriation bills the constitution limits them to the “ ordinary expenses of the executive, legislative and judicial departments,” and some other enumerated matters, and every valid appropriation in this form must appear to be reasonably within the description of “ or
Judgment reversed and mandamus ordered to be awarded as prayed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.