Dale v. Blue Mountain Manufacturing Co.

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Dale v. Blue Mountain Manufacturing Co., 167 Pa. 402 (Pa. 1895)
31 A. 633; 1895 Pa. LEXIS 920
Dean, McCollum, Mitchell, Stekrett, Williams

Dale v. Blue Mountain Manufacturing Co.

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam,

In this case, the summons was returned by the sheriff: “ Served the Blue Mountain Manufacturing Company, a corporation under the laws of Pennsylvania, by giving, June 22, 1893, a true and attested copy of the within writ to D. B. Fisher, general manager of said company and making known to him the contents thereof.” Judgment having been entered against defendant company for want of an affidavit of defense, a rule was taken to set aside the sheriff’s return and strike off the judgment. That rule was made absolute, and hence this appeal, in which the sole question is whether the sheriff’s return shows a •sufficient service of the writ. The learned judge rightly held that the service was insufficient because it was not made on the “ president or other principal officer, or on the cashier, treasurer, secretary or chief clerk ” of the corporation defendant, as required by the act of June 13,1836, section 41. As shown by the court below, the words, “ president or other principal officer,” mean the chief executive officer of the corporation, whether called chairman, president, or by any other title, and were not intended to include “general manager.” The question is so fully and satisfactorily considered by the learned judge of the ■common pleas that further comment is unnecessary.

We affirm the judgment on his opinion.

Judgment affirmed.

Reference

Full Case Name
Alfred A. Dale v. Blue Mountain Manufacturing Company
Cited By
4 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
Practice, O. P. — Service of process — Corporations—Act of June 13,1836, sec. 41. Under the act of June 13, 1836, sec. 41, P. L. 579, the person referred to as the “ president or other principal officer” means the chief executive officer of the corporation, though called president, chairman, or by any other title. Under the acts of March 17, 1856, P. L. 388, March 21, 1842, P. L. 145, and March 15, 1847, P. L. 261, the words “ manager” or “ director” are synonymous, and mean one of the body of persons appointed pursuant to the charter or by-laws of the corporation to manage its affairs. In a suit against a corporation the sheriff’s return was as follows: “ Served the Blue Mountain Manufacturing Company, a corporation under the laws of Pennsylvania, by giving, June 22, 1893, a true and attested copy of the within writ to D. B. Fisher, general manager of said company and making known to him the contents thereof.” There was no appearance for the defendant. A judgment was entered against him for want of an affidavit of defense. Held, the judgment was void and should be stricken off..