Griel's Estate
Griel's Estate
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This appeal involves the construction of section 8 of the act of February 22,1821, P. L. 57, prescribing, inter alia, that “the fees to be received by the clerk of the orphans’ court shall be as follows: . . . . All proceedings for the sale of real estate, recognizance or confirmation, recording and copy, three dollars.”
The facts, so far as they are material, are sufficiently set forth
If the single question now before us had been expressly ruled by this court in the case referred to, there would be some force in the position assumed by the learned judge ; but, neither that, nor any other question of similar import was passed upon by this court, because, as to the construction of the clause above quoted, the two judges, who alone heard and considered the case, differed in opinion, and hence the decree of the orphans’ court was permitted to stand, except as to matters in which both judges concurred. In other words, as to the question of construction now before us, the decree of the court below stood as affirmed by a divided court. That is not a decree or judgment of this court, in support of which the rulé of stare decisis can be successfully invoked. That principle applies only to
We are clearly of opinion that the clause referred to was rightly construed by the learned auditor, and his report, awarding appellant $189, or a fee of $3.00, for each of the sixty-three separate sales of decedent’s real estate, made and confirmed to the respective purchasers. As was clearly shown by Mr. Justice Gibson, in the case above cited, that is the only construction of the clause in question that gives proper effect to the legislative intention.
Decree reversed with costs to be paid by the appellee, and it is ordered and decreed that the report of the auditor be confirmed and the fund be distributed in accordance therewith.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Jacob Griel's Estate. Will's Appeal
- Cited By
- 11 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Costs—Orphans' court sale—Fees of clerk of orphans' court—Act of February 22, 1821, sec. 8. Under the act of February 22, 1821, see. 8, P. L. 57, providing that the fees to be received by the clerk of the orphans’ court shall be in “ All proceedings for the sale of real estate, recognizances or confirmation, recording and copy, three dollars, ” the clerk is entitled, where the estate is sold in purparts to different purchasers, to a fee of three dollars for each sale, regarding each of the different purchasers as representing a sale. Stare decisis—Effect of judgment or decree affirmed by divided court. A judgment or decree of a lower court affirmed in the Supreme Court by a divided court, is not a decree or judgment by the Supreme Court in support of which the rule of stare decisis can be successfully invoked.