Fisher v. Hestonville, Mantua & Fairmount Passenger Railway Co.
Cases that cite this one
40 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Wolfe v. Riggle (Pa. 1962)
- Philadelphia Suburban Transportation Co. v. DiFrancesco (Pa. 1949)
- In re Adoption of R.J.S. (Pa. Super. Ct. 2005)
- Commonwealth v. Brewer (Pa. Super. Ct. 1952)
- McFadden v. Hanft (Pa. Super. Ct. 1950)
- McFadden v. Hanft (Pa. Super. Ct. 1949)
- Shinn v. Stemler (Pa. Super. Ct. 1948)
- Bergen v. Lit Bros. (Pa. 1946)
- York v. George (Pa. 1944)
- Commonwealth v. Heller (Pa. Super. Ct. 1941)
- Kingsdorf v. Frank Gamburg, Inc. (Pa. Super. Ct. 1941)
- Commonwealth v. Le Grand (Pa. 1939)
- Rome Sales & Service Station v. Finch (Pa. Super. Ct. 1935)
- Giles v. Ryan (Pa. 1934)
- Hornick v. Bethlehem Mines Corp. (Pa. 1932)
- Evans v. Freeman (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Pennsylvania 1905)
- Phillips Adoption (Somerset County Orphans' Court 1957)
- Commonwealth v. Ashe (Juniata County Court of Oyer and Terminer 1942)
- Collins v. Pennsylvania Indemnity Corp. (Mercer County Court of Common Pleas 1940)
- Frantz v. Philadelphia (Pa. 1939)
- Dellacasse v. Floyd Exrs. (Pa. 1938)
- Dormont Motors, Inc. for Use v. Hoerr (Pa. Super. Ct. 1938)
- Commonwealth v. Ashe (Erie County Court of Oyer and Terminer 1937)
- Salus v. Fogel (Pa. 1930)
- Andrews's Adoption (Erie County Orphans' Court 1929)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The remedy for wrongful verdicts by new trial was established in England before the foundation of Pennsylvania. It was therefore part of the common law of jury trials which the colonists brought with them, and has always been exercised here: Kalbach v. Fisher, 1 Rawle, 323. The older remedies of audita querela and error coram nobis, though in existence here, have in practice been superseded by the more convenient instrument of a new trial.
The principles on which the authority rests are well settled. Until judgment the verdict is under control of the court by virtue of its common-law powers, as the judge is an essential constituent of the tribunal for jury trial, and may refuse judgment and set aside the verdict for any reason which appeals to his judicial discretion. It is not necessary that his reason should appear of record, though it is the better practice that it should : Shabswood, J., King v. Brooks, 72 Pa. 363. And even after judgment the court may during the term at which it was entered, allow a rule for new trial nunc pro tunc and make it absolute: Lance v. Bonnell, 105 Pa. 46. But at the expiration of the term at which it was entered the common-law power to set aside a judgment regular on its face, ends: King v. Brooks, supra. The further control of the court over it for that purpose is equitable, and was asserted originally by bill in chancery: Cochran v. Eldridge, 49 Pa. 365. The ground of its exercise therefore is exceptional, and should appear of record, so that it may clearly appear “ that it is not a mere arbitrary exercise of discretion: ” King v. Brooks, supra.
In the present case the verdict was rendered, a rule for new trial discharged, and judgment on the verdict entered during the December term, 1895. In November, 1896, a second rule for new trial was granted, and in December, 1896, made absolute. No reasons appear of record for this action of the court. It is claimed by the appellee that it was based on the fraud of the plaintiff and his interpreter by which the verdict was obtained through false interpretation of the testimony. And this seems to be sustained by the depositions. But they are not regularly before us and do not even appear to have been filed of record. There can be no question that the rule that fraud vitiates everything into which it enters applies to verdicts and
The judgment is reversed, and the record remitted with leave to the defendant, appellee, to file a petition nunc pro tunc, setting forth the grounds for new trial and for further proceedings by the court thereupon.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.