City of Lancaster v. Frescoln
City of Lancaster v. Frescoln
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This, action is upon a bond given to secure the compliance by S. W. Frescoln with the provisions of a contract into which he entered with the city of Lancaster for the construction of a reservoir. The contract provides among other things that Frescoln shall pay or secure the wages for labor and the price of materials used. The conditions of the bond are that he shall complete the work in a satisfactory manner; that he shall pay or secure the wages of laborers and the price of materials, and that he shall not employ alien labor. The action is brought in the name of the city of Lancaster to the use of three parties who furnished materials. The principal in the bond was not served, and the defense is made by the American Surety Company in its own interest only.
The main grounds of defense set up in the affidavit filed by the surety company are: first, that the bond imposes upon it ho liability to the use plaintiffs; secondly, that all matters between it and the legal plaintiff arising out of the contract were adjudicated in an action brought on the contract by S. W. Frescoln against the city of Lancaster in which he recovered $13,750, the balance found to be due him for constructing the reservoir.
A general ordinance of the city of Lancaster provides that contractors for city work shall be required to give additional bonds to the city for the use of any persons who may be aggrieved by their failure to pay for work done or materials furnished. The special ordinance authorizing the construction of the reservoir and awarding the contract required the contractor to enter security for the faithful performance of the contract.
The action brought by S. W. Frescoln against the city to recover the balance claimed to be due him under the contract necessarily included every matter touching this right. The rule that what has once been judicially determined shall not again be made the subject of litigation extends to every question in the proceeding which was legally cognizable. That the claims for labor and materials were unpaid by the plaintiffs was a proper ground of defense in that action, and all of these matters must now be considered as conclusively adjudicated. The city could not maintain this action, and as the use plaintiffs here have no standing except upon the city’s rights it follows that they cannot recover.
The judgment is reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- City of Lancaster, to the use of The Penn Iron Company, Limited v. Samuel W. Frescoln and the American Surety Company
- Cited By
- 23 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Principal and surety—Bond— Construction of bond. In an action against a surety, the obligation of a bond cannot be extended beyond the plain import of the words used. Bes adjudicata—Scope of the rule. The rule that what has once been judicially determined shall not again be made the subject of litigation, extends to every question in the proceeding which was legally cognizable. Principal and surety—Contractor's bond to municipality—Bes adjudicata. Under an ordinance requiring a municipal contractor to enter security for the faithful performance of the contract, the conditions of the contractor’s bond were that he should complete the work in a satisfactory manner, and pay or secure the wages of laborers and the price of materials used. An action was brought on the bond in the name of the city to the use of certain persons who furnished materials. It appeared that the contractor had previously sued the city and recovered a balance on his contract. A general ordinance of the city provided that contractors should give additional bonds to the city for the use of any person who might be aggrieved by their failure to pay for work done or materials furnished, but no additional bond was given. Held, (1) that the bond did not authorize arecovery to the use of laborers and material men; (2) that the action could not be maintained as the matters in dispute had been judicially determined in the action between the contractor and the city.