Kellow v. City of Scranton

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Kellow v. City of Scranton, 195 Pa. 134 (Pa. 1900)
45 A. 676; 1900 Pa. LEXIS 599
Cttbiam, Dean, Een, Fell, McCollum, Mitchell

Kellow v. City of Scranton

Opinion of the Court

Pee Cttbiam,

That there was a decided depression in the level surface of the pavement of which the city had notice but failed to repair, and that it was concealed by the snow and slush which prevailed at the moment of the accident, were palpable facts as to which there was no dispute. It was certainly a proper question of fact under all the testimony whether the plaintiff fell upon stepping into the depression of the surface, and the referee has found that she did. There was no evidence which would suffice to sustain a charge of contributory negligence. The assignments of error are dismissed.

Judgment affirmed.

Reference

Full Case Name
Ella Kellow v. City of Scranton
Cited By
5 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
Negligence—Municipalities—Defective sidewalk. A municipality had notice of a decided depression in the level surface of the pavement of a street and failed to repair it, and the plaintiff having fallen and been injured while walking along the pavement, by reason of stepping into the depression, at that time concealed by snow and slush, she was entitled to recover, there being no sufficient evidence of contributory negligence.