Ike's Estate
Ike's Estate
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This is an appeal from a decree made by the orphans’ court
To his petition to the orphans’ court for an order to sell the real estate of the decedent for the payment of debts, the administrator, Jerry Ike, appended the usual schedule of liabilities, in which was included the sum of $9,000 due to himself on judgment notes. The real estate was sold, exceptions were filed by the appellee to the confirmation of the sale, and she subsequently presented her petition to the court below, asking, for reasons therein set forth, that an issue be awarded to determine the validity of the several notes of her husband, making up. the $9,000 item of liability in the schedule of debts appended to the application for the order of sale. An answer to this petition was filed by the appellant, and, after hearing before an examiner, the court, in a well-considered opinion, refused the issue. No useful purpose can now be served by reviewing, simply to sanction them, the reasons given by the learned judge of the court below in denying appellant’s petition. The issue asked for was not of right, but depended upon the discretion of the court, under the facts as developed s Kates’s Appeal, 148 Pa. 471. There was not only no abuse of this discretion, but in our judgment, upon a review of the whole record, a proper exercise of it.
If these notes of the decedent, held by the administrator, his father, ought not to be paid, the appellee can still, at the proper time, when the administration account is filed and the fund in the hands of the administrator is brought before
The first, third, fourth, fifth and sixth specifications of error are overruled, the appeal is dismissed and the decree affirmed at the cost of the appellant.
Reference
- Status
- is bound to show affirmatively that he holds the obligations under a hostile title and did not find the notes in question among the papers of the decedent after death of said decedent.</p> <p>Let us consider said second proposition first. Said contention of counsel is founded
- Syllabus
- Executors and administrators—Sale of real estate for payment of debts— Issue to determine validity of notes held by administrator. Where an administrator in petitioning the court for an order to sell real estate for the payment of debts includes in the schedule of debts certain notes of the decedent to himself, and the widow of the decedent petitions the court for an issue to determine the validity of such notes, the issue asked for is not of right, but depends upon the discretion of the court, and the Supreme Court will not review the exercise of such discretion where no abuse of it has been shown. In such a case if the court refuses the issue, the widow may still, when the administration account is filed and the fund is brought before the court for distribution contest the validity of the notes, and even then the issue before denied, may be awarded by the court.