South Western State Normal School's Case
South Western State Normal School's Case
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The facts in this case appear in the opinion of the Superior Court, 26 Pa. Superior Ct. 99, and need not be repeated here. In its petition to the court below, the South Western State Normal School set forth that a plot of thirty-six lots, known as Morgan’s Addition to California, Pa., and recorded in the office of the recorder of deeds for Washington county, was lately laid out by Lewis W. Morgan, and lots were sold therefrom with reference to certain streets and alleys marked upon the said plan; that it had purchased twelve of these lots for campus purposes ; that through them run Main street, fifty feet wide, and other streets and alleys of different widths, all being on the said plan ; that after it had purchased these lots it proceeded to condemn the streets and alleys running through them and adjoining them on the north and south, and prayed, first, for the approval of its bond to secure to the owners of other lots on the plot having rights of way or easements over the said streets and alleys the damages sustained by its condemnation of them; and, second, that the title to the real estate, which it held within the boundaries described in its petition, be decreed to be free of any easement or right of way on account of the location of the said streets and alleys thereon, subject to the payment of such damages as may be agreed upon or assessed according to law. The petition was filed under the Act of July 10, 1901, P. L. 632, authorizing the condemnation of real estate needed for the use of state normal schools. Whether the act is invalid for the reason that the ground which it authorizes to be so taken is not for a public use, is not the question raised in this proceeding. It is whether the appellant is authorized by the act to do what it has undertaken to do.
For the reason that the appellant has not been authorized to condemn the streets and alleys set forth in its petition, the decree of the Superior Court affirming the decree of the court below is affirmed, with costs to the appellee.
Reference
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Deed — Plan of lots — Streets and alleys — Dedication. A sale of lots according to a plan implies a grant or covenant to each purchaser that the streets and alleys on the plan shall be forever opened to the use of the public, and operates as a dedication of them to public use. Such dedication cannot be revoked by the vendor, and the purchaser of each lot abutting on one of the streets or alleys, as well as all other persons purchasing and owning lots on the plan, may assert the public character of the streets and alleys, and the right of the public to use them. Eminent domain — State normal school — Condemnation of streets — Act of July 10,. 1901, P. L. 632. There is nothing in the Act of July 10, 1901, P. L. 632, which authorizes a state normal school to condemn for a campus, streets and alleys dedicated by a plan of lots to public use. Property already devoted to public use is subject to eminent domain and may be taken for other public uses; but, while this is true, it cannot be taken without legislative authority expressly conferred or arising by necessary implication.