Hicks v. Williamsport
Hicks v. Williamsport
Opinion of the Court
The city of Williamsport in 1900 adopted a grade for two intersecting streets that had been laid out and opened many years before. The new paper grade differed somewhat from the actual surface of the streets and was made with a view to future improvements. No legislative action was ever taken by the city for the grading of these streets. In 1909, the city engineer set stakes at the intersection where the plaintiff’s lot is situate in accordance with the new grade and the street commissioner constructed a concrete crossing which was lower than the original surface of the street
It is the physical change and not the mere establishment of a grade on the official plan that gives a right of action and damages are not recoverable for a change of grade until the actual work on the ground is begun. Howley v. Pittsburgh, 204 Pa. 428; Devlin v. Philadelphia, 206 Pa. 518; and the grading could be done only by the authority of the city councils exercised in the manner prescribed by law. Kittanning Borough v. Thompson, 211 Pa. 169. The work done by the street commissioner was not done in pursuance of any authority by the city to change the grade and without such authority by proper legislative action, no change of grade could be made. In this proceeding the plaintiff was not entitled to recover.
The judgment is affirmed.
Reference
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Hoad law — Change of grade — Physical change — Authority of councils. Damages are not recoverable for a change of grade of a street until the actual work on the ground is begun. It is the physical change and not the mere establishment of the grade on the official plan that gives the right, and such grading must be done only by the authority of the city councils exercised in the manner prescribed by law. Work done by a street commissioner without authority of a city ordinance does not constitute a legal change of grade which will confer upon the owner of abutting property a right for damages.