Sterling v. H. F. Watson Co.
Sterling v. H. F. Watson Co.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
This case was so carefully considered and so properly decided by the learned court below that but little if anything of value can be added by an extended discussion of the points involved in the controversy here. The appellant corporation desires to retire its preferred shares of stock as it has the right to do upon the conditions contained in the certificates of the preferred shareholders. Appellant is a Pennsylvania corporation and has the power to issue both preferred and common stock. The certificates representing preferred stock contain the following provisions: “The stock represented by this certificate is a portion of the preferred stock authorized by the stockholders, in pursuance of the Acts of Assembly of April 18, 1874, P. L. 61; April 3, 1872, P. L. 37, and April 28, 1873, P. L. 79, is entitled to cumulative semi-annual dividends of four per. cent, each
We cannot agree with the learned counsel for appellant that the par value of the new stock issued to preferred shareholders should be regarded as a payment on account of the semi-annual dividends to which they were entitled. There is nothing in the contract of the parties to warrant the payment of semi-annual dividends by the issue of new stock. These dividends must be paid out of net earnings and not by the issue of new; stock.
Decree affirmed at the cost of appellant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Sterling v. H. F. Watson Company
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Corporations — Preferred stock — Retirement—Stock dividend. Where preferred stock was issued by a corporation, the certificates of which contained the following provision: “The stock represented by this certificate is a portion of the preferred stock authorized by the stockholders, in pursuance of the Acts of Assembly of April 18, 1874, P. L. 61; April 3, 1872, P. L. 37, and April 28, 1873, P. L. 79, is entitled to cumulative semi-annual dividends of four per cent, each on the par value of the Stock, payable from the net earnings of the company; and is subject to the right of the H. F. Watson Company, at its option, to retire and extinguish the same, upon the payment to the owner thereof of all arrears of dividends, and the par value thereof, at any time after April 6, 1907,” the corporation cannot compel the holders to surrender their stock for purposes of redemption, except upon payment in cash of accumulated dividends and the par value of the stock. The fact that subsequent to the issuance of the preferred stock, a stock dividend had been declared by the corporation, some of which stock was distributed to the preferred stockholders, does not affect their rights. Such new Stock, if so distributed, cannot be regarded as a payment on account of the semi-annual dividends to be paid in cash as a preference on the par value of the preferred stock out of the net earnings.