Commonwealth v. Highspire Distillery Co.
Commonwealth v. Highspire Distillery Co.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The distillery company was formed as a limited partnership in 1892 with a capital of $25,000.00. In 1909 its capital was increased in due form of law to $100,000.00, and the Commonwealth now claims the right to collect a bonus on the increase of $75,000.00. Limited partnerships are required to pay a bonus of one-third of one per centum upon their capital or any increase thereof by the Act of May 8, 1901, P. L. 149. This act was passed as a revenue measure, which purpose was declared in its title. The evident intention of the legislature was to place limited partnerships and other associations of like character upon the same basis as corporations having» capital stock in so far as the payment of a bonus for the privilege of issuing capital and increasing the same from time to time is concerned. It is contended for appellee that this act is prospective in
Learned counsel for appellee rely on Com. v. Railroad Co., 207 Pa. 154; Com. v. Railway Co., 207 Pa. 160; Com. v. Danville Bessemer Co., 207 Pa. 302, and Com. v. American Steel Hoop Co., 226 Pa. 6, to support their contention in the case at bar. All of these cases are differentiated by their facts from the present case and are not authority for the position here asserted. We have examined each of these cases carefully and without going into an elaborate discussion of the principle there involved, we only deem it necessary to say that they were ruled on their peculiar facts and cannot be regarded as authority for the general doctrine here set up that the Commonwealth enters into a contract with a corporation or a limited partnership at the time of its formation not to charge any bonus on increases of capital stock subsequently made, even if the legislature so provides. The general application of such a doctrine would run counter to the great weight of authority, not only here but elsewhere, and could not be justified by reason and precedent.
Our conclusion is that the Commonwealth is entitled to collect a bonus on the increase of capital made by appellee in 1909.
Judgment reversed and .record remitted with directions to enter judgment in favor of the Commonwealth in accordance with the views herein expressed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Commonwealth v. Highspire Distillery Company, Ltd.
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Taxation — Limited partnerships — Increase of capital stoclc— Bonus — Act of May 8, 1901, P. L. 149 — Partnerships formed prior to the act. The Act of May 8, 1901, P. L. 149, requiring limited partnerships to pay a bonus of one-third of one per centum upon their capital, or any increase thereof, is applicable to increases of capital stock made subsequently by a limited partnership formed prior to the date of the act.