Stark's Estate
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Stark's Estate, 264 Pa. 232 (Pa. 1919)
107 A. 699; 1919 Pa. LEXIS 627
Brown, Cubiam, Frazer, Kephart, Moschzisker, Stewart
Stark's Estate
Opinion of the Court
The devise of Perry Stark to his daughter, Georgianna, was absolute, for she survived his wife. His provision that if she should die “leaving no issue of her body living at her death,” then over to certain named persons, was not a limitation or curtailment of the devise, but simply alternative or substitutionary and to take effect only on the death of the daughter in his lifetime: Mickley’s App., 92 Pa. 514; Morrison v. Truby, 145 Pa. 540; McAlpin’s Est., 211 Pa. 26. The fee in the farm of the testator undoubtedly vested in the daughter, and the petition for its partition by one having no interest in it was properly dismissed.
Decree affirmed at appellant’s costs.
Reference
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Wills — Construction—Estate in fee simple — Gift to daughter— Death in lifetime of testator — Substitutionary gift. 1. Where a testator gives the “absolute control” of all of his estate to his wife together with the profits and income thereof, subject to the comfortable living and support of his daughter, and in case of the death of the daughter in the wife’s lifetime, then to the wife in fee simple, but if the daughter outlives the wife, then the absolute control of the property remaining at the death of the wife, to the daughter together with the profits and income thereof as long as she lives, and at her death to her heirs is a gift in fee simple to the daughter, surviving the testator and his wife, and is not cut down by a subsequent clause of the will providing that in case the daughter “should die leaving no issue of her body living at her death,” then the property shall vest in fee simple in other persons named. 2. Such latter clause is not a limitation or curtailment of tbe devise, but is simply alternative or substitutionary, and to take effect only on the death of the daughter in testator’s lifetime.