Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1936

Commonwealth v. Globe Furnishing Co.

Commonwealth v. Globe Furnishing Co.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Decided October 7, 1936 · Appeal · Cueiam, Kephart, Schaffer, Maxey, Drew, Linn, Stern, Barnes
188 A. 170; 324 Pa. 180; 1936 Pa. LEXIS 492

Counsel

Samuel Kaufman , with him Louis J. Bloch, S. Leo Ruslander and Louis Caplan , for appellant. Francis P. Anton, Charles J. Margiotti , Attorney General, and E. Russell Shockley , Deputy Attorney General, for appellee, were not heard.

Commonwealth v. Globe Furnishing Co.

Opinion of the Court

Pee Cueiam,

Appellant contends that if the cash received from bailment leases is included within the gross volume of its business for purposes of assessing the mercantile license tax, it will amount to double taxation because the value of the leased goods is also included within its property valuation for capital stock tax purposes. But it is established that double taxation exists only where the subject of both taxes is the same. The capital stock tax is a property tax; the mercantile license tax is a tax on the privilege of doing business in a certain manner. This distinction has been previously noted in Commonwealth v. Bailey, Banks & Biddle Co., 20 Pa. Superior Ct. 210, where a similar contention was ruled upon adversely to appellant. See also Commonwealth v. Harrisburg L. & P. Co., 284 Pa. 175, 179. Appellant’s other contentions are all fully answered in the opinion of the court below.

Judgment affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.