Mellon National Bank & Trust Co. v. Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment, Appeals & Review
Mellon National Bank & Trust Co. v. Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment, Appeals & Review
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
A narrow question is presented: Is the Personal Property Tax imposed by the Act of June 17, 1913,
The Citizens National Bank of Washington was trustee for various trusts. The Mellon National Bank and Trust Company purchased substantially all of the assets of the Citizens National Bank including its bank building, and assumed its deposit liabilities. Pursuant to the purchase agreement the Mellon Bank was appointed by the Orphans’ Court of Washington County successor-fiduciary in a majority of the trusts of which the Citizens Bank had been trustee. The Mellon Bank took possession of the assets of these trust estates, including the presently taxable securities, and they were thereafter, held in the-vaults, or- offices of the Mellon Bank at its Union Trust office in the City of Pittsburgh. The Citizens National Bank of Washington voluntarily liquidated and thereafter-ceased to exist. The Mellon Bank retained, as. a branch office, the banking premises formerly owned by the Citizens Bank.
While it is not set forth in the Stipulation of Facts which the parties agreed to, it is a matter of common knowledge that -all of the important trust problems, including the purchase and sale of securities, are decided at the principal office of the bank and that these trusts are-managed and-administered in the-prineipal office of the bank rather than in an outlying branch office. . There may .be. discussions and conferences in the branch office between cestui que .tru'sten.t and -ah
The lower Court correctly held that the Personal Property Tax on the securities in the trusts in question was payable to Allegheny County. Section 2 of the Act of June 17, 1913, provided, prior to the amendment of May 20, 1949, with respect to a Personal Property Tax imposed upon securities constituting part of the principal of a trust estate as follows: “Provided, That any corporation, joint-stock association, or limited partnership, doing business in more than one county, shall be liable to make such return only in the county in which its principal office
There is no merit in this contention because the two banks Avere not consolidated.
The Stipulation of Facts sets forth that the agreement dated October 11, 1948, under which the Mellon National Bank and Trust Company purchased substantially all of the assets of the Citizens National Bank of Washington “Avas not entered into and the acts done pursuant thereto Avere not carried out under the provisions of . . . the Act of November 7, 1918, c 209, §1, 40 Stat, 1043, USCA Tit. 12, §33, as amended, which recites the procedure for the statutory consolidation of national banks.” The Stipulation further recites that this agreement Avas entered into with the approval of the Comptroller of the Currency in accordance with the Act of February 25,1927. Not only did the Stipulation recite that the purchase of assets, the establishment of a branch bank, and other acts pursuant to the agreement of October 11, 1948, were not done under the Federal Act providing for the statutory consolidation
It is clear, therefore, that the transaction entered into between these two banking institutions was not a consolidation within the meaning of the Personal Property Tax Act amendment of May 20, 1949, supra, and the Personal Property Tax must be paid to the County of Allegheny.
The order of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County is affirmed.
P. L. 507.
P. L. 1534, 72 PS 4841.
Italics ours.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Mellon National Bank and Trust Company v. Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment, Appeals and Review, (et al., Appellant)
- Status
- Published