Yates v. Township of McKean

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania September 26, 2007

Yates v. Township of McKean, 931 A.2d 639 (Pa. 2007)

593 Pa. 436; 2007 Pa. LEXIS 2009

Cappy, Eakin

Opinion of the Court

*437 ORDER

PER CURIAM.

AND NOW, this 26th day of September, 2007, the Order of the Court of Common Pleas of Erie County is affirmed.

Chief Justice CAPPY files a concurring statement. Justice EAKIN files a concurring statement.

Concurring Opinion

Chief Justice CAPPY,

concurring.

I join the Court in its per curiam order. Although I previously joined Mr. Justice Eakin in his dissenting opinion in Burger v. School Board of the McGuffey School District, 923 A.2d 1155 (2007), that case now stands as a majority precedent in this Court, and therefore, stare decisis in this instance.

Concurring Opinion

Justice EAKIN,

concurring.

I join the per curiam affirmance. While I remain of the opinion expressed in my dissent in Burger v. School Board of the McGuffey School District, 923 A.2d 1155, 1167 (2007) (Eakin, J., dissenting), I recognize the precedential value of Burger’s majority.

Reference

Full Case Name: John YATES and John L. Dombrowski, v. TOWNSHIP OF McKEAN, Erie County, Pennsylvania, Edward Hess, Supervisor, James Guckes, Supervisor, McKean Township Sewer Authority, Karl Hughes, Member, Michael Wheeling, Member, Elizabeth Riechert, Member, Eric Dedrick, an Individual, and Edward Hess, Individually. Appeal of Edward Hess, Individual and Eric Dedrick, Individual. Appeal of Edward Hess, Individual and Eric Dedrick, Individual
Cited By: 3 cases
Status: Published