Miller v. Royal Insurance Co.
Miller v. Royal Insurance Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the following opinion:
This action is upon a policy of fire insurance. It is submitted upon both special and general demurrer to the declaration. It is urged as ground for special demurrer that the plaintiff has not capacity to sue. The power was given him to do so by the order appointing him; this is averred in the declaration, and it is immaterial whether he is called a special master or
The averments of the declaration are, for the most part, stated upon belief and information. The statements of a pleading should be definite and precise. If within the party’s knowledge they should be stated in absolute form. If presumptively, from the facts set out, they are within the defendant’s knowledge, and not within the plaintiff’s, or mainly within the defendant’s knowledge, as much precision is not necessary as would otherwise be required. It may be said that the plaintiff, being but a special master, should be presumed to have no personal knowledge of the facts of the case, but in my opinion he should either so aver, or state them as of his own knowledge and in absolute form; and the declaration appearing otherwise sufficient and in proper form the general demurrer to it is sustained only upon the ground indicated.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- ROBERT A. MILLER, Special Master v. ROYAL INSURANCE COMPANY
- Status
- Published