United States v. Butler
United States v. Butler
Opinion of the Court
delivered the following opinion:
This is a question as to tlie allowance of mileage to a witness for tbe government. II. E. Keim, living at Aibonito, was summoned as a witness on behalf of the United States to testify before the commissioner in San Juan. The distance between the two places is 50 miles. The witness makes affidavit that, in order to be present at the hearing before the commissioner, he had to hire a coach for $8 to bring him to San Juan in time for the hearing before the commissioner; and that the cheapest mode of conveyance for his return will cost him $4, or $12 in
A witness, unlike a juryman, is not entitled to the per diem while en route to and from a court. His mileage is all he gets, during that time. He has no right, even in order to be at the hearing in time, to adopt an expensive mode of travel, and then claim that he is entitled to be reimbursed. This witness was. a private individual; and In such case there is no law authorizing the allowance of his actual expenses. The question, therefore, in this case is, "What rate of mileage is to be allowed ? In this instance, if the wetness can be allowed but 5 cents per mile, he will be the loser, even allowdng that he had adopted the ordinary mail coach travel. This hardship, however, must not be allowed to violate the lawq if it does not allow more. The general law (§ 848, H. S. Rev. Stat., U. S. Comp. Stat. 1901, p. 654) provides: “For each day’s attendance in court, or before any officer pursuant to law, $1.50, and 5 cents a mile for going from his place of residence to the place of trial or hearing, and 5 cents a mile for returning.” This statute is at least as. old as 1853. The Congress of the United States by act of August 3d, 1892 (27 Stat. at L. 347, chap. 361, U. S. Comp. Stat. 1901, p. 655) provided that jurors and witnesses in the United States courts in certain western statés and in the territories of New Mexico, Arizona, and Utah should be entitled to 15 cents for each mile necessarily traveled over any stage line or by private conveyance, and 5 cents for each mile over any railway, in going to and returning from said courts. It was manifest justice to make this increase owing to the greater cost of travel
This special law relating to Porto Rico must, therefore, be held not to apply to a hearing before a United States commissioner, but only as to the court; and the claim of the witness for more than 5 cents per mile mileage is disallowed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- UNITED STATES v. BENJAMIN F. BUTLER. H. E. KEIM
- Status
- Published