People v. Villegas
People v. Villegas
Opinion of the Court
delivered the following opinion of the court:
This is an appeal taken from a judgment rendered by the District Court of San Juan in a cause instituted against Modesto Villegas, Tomás Crispin, Félix Encarnación and Eusta-quio Aquino, for assault and battery. The defendants were tried by a jury and sentenced as follows: Modesto Villegas, to the penalty of one year and six months’ imprisonment, and the others to two years and six months each; together with a proportional part of the costs upon each. In the record is found a bill of exceptions, duly signed by the presiding judge, based entirely upon a consideration of the evidence by the jury. As this court has held, and now repeats, the jury is the
The only point which still merits consideration is not found in the bill of exceptions, where it should have been, but was urged orally on the trial. It appears that the court ruled that the challenges should first be taken for cause and after-wards peremptorily with respect to each juror at the time he presented himself to the court. To this ruling the attorney for the defense took an exception, claiming the right which he had to reserve the peremptory challenges until the jury was formed. When the jury had been formed and only two peremptory challenges had been taken by the attorney for the defense, the court permitted him to interpose four challenges more, which, together with the two he had already taken, made a, total of six, which is the number which he had a right to exercise. But the court would not have committed any error even if it had adhered in every respect to the ruling which it first made, because the law provides that the challenge must be taken when the juror appears, and before he is sworn to try the cause; but the court may for cause permit it to be taken after the juror is sworn, and before the jury is completed, leaving it to the discretion of the court.
The judgment of the district couri was rendered on November 20, 1903, and the hearing took place before this court
Bedded accordingly.. I
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.