People v. La Compañía de Lanchas del Comercio
People v. La Compañía de Lanchas del Comercio
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This case originated in the justice of the peace court of Ponce, upon a complaint made on November 20, 1909, by Pedro Vivas Valdivieso, municipal inspector, against the Compañía de Lanchas del Comercio, for violation of the mu
Judgment having been rendered on November 22 by the justice of the peace court, the defendant took an appeal therefrom to the District Court of Ponce, which, after holding a new trial, condemned the defendant company to pay a fine of $15 and costs and, in case of failure to pay the fine, to serve one day in jail for each dollar which it might so fail to pay, and this judgment was also appealed to the Supreme Court by the Compañía de Lanchas del Comercio.
No bill of exceptions or statement of the case has come up in the record, nor has the appellant filed any written brief or made any oral argument in support of the appeal. Upon an examination of the complaint, we find that the facts therein alleged constitute the offense defined in section 81 of the Municipal Law, approved March 8, 1906, and punished by a fine of $15, by section 5 of the ordinance passed by the municipal council of Ponce, to govern the payment of municipal taxes and licenses, and for the use of the waters of the acqueduct and other purposes.
In regard to the judgment, it appears that the trial court has left it to the choice of the defendant to either pay the $15 fine or serve the jail sentence, when, as a matter of fact, the payment of the fine is obligatory because it constitutes a lien according to the provisions of section 325 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Furthermore, section 460 of the Code above referred to requires that, where a fine is imposed upon a company, it may be collected by virtue of the order imposing it, by the officer of the court, out of its real or personal property.
. Affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.