People v. Sánchez
People v. Sánchez
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
On October 7, 1909, a sworn complaint was filed in the municipal court of Ponce by Sergeant Soto of the insular
An appeal was taken to the district court where the case was tried de novo, and the court, on April 29, 1910, found Inocencio Sánchez guilty of the crime of false representation and sentenced Mm to one year in prison.
An appeal having been taken from the judgment of the district, court to this court, the hearing was had on October 25,-1910, without the appearance of the appellant.
There is no bill of exceptions or statement of facts in the record, nor does it appear that any fundamental error whatever was committed which could serve for the reversal of the judgment appealed from.
The District Court of Ponce imposed a greater punishment on the accused than that imposed by the municipal court of Tauco, and we think in so doing it acted within the powers conferred upon it by law.
In cases of appeals from municipal courts to district courts, the latter should not confine their action to a reversal or affirmance of the judgment appealed from, but they must decide the case on the pleadings and the evidence. “All cases that are triable before the justices of the peace, or before the municipal courts, when appealed to the district court, shall be tried on the original complaint and warrant, and the trial in the district court shall be de novo.” (Sec. 3 of the Code of Crim. Proc., as amended by the' Act of March 28, 1904,. Laws of P. P., 1905, p. 10.)
Upon an examination of the complaint or warrant, which is the basis of the proceeding, and the plea of the defendant,,
The appeal must be dismissed and the judgment appealed from, affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.