Cruz v. Quiñones
Cruz v. Quiñones
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This was a case in which the District Court of Ponce declared that the complainants were the natural children of the defendant. The judgment was appealed and affirmed. This appeal relates to a memorandum of costs. The appellant maintains that an award of $600 counsel fees is excessive, but concedes, of course, that the award of counsel fees is within the sound discretion of the court.
In the record before us, neither the pleadings nor the proof taken at the trial has been certified to us. We have hence not sufficient data to make an inquiry into the question of whether the court below abused its discretion. We have decided under these conditions that unless it a-ppeared that the amount awarded was excessive for any case of its kind, we were not in a position to review. Preston v. Vázquez, 31 P. R. R. 841; Lassalle v. Hilla, 29 P. R. R. 470. This award of Counsel fees in a hard fought filiation suit does not appear to.be excessive.
The only matter that-at all distinguishes this case from
The order appealed from must be
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.