Supreme Court of Puerto Rico, 1932

Vergara Garced v. Pérez

Vergara Garced v. Pérez
Supreme Court of Puerto Rico · Decided November 28, 1932 · Hutchison
44 P.R. 140

Vergara Garced v. Pérez

Opinion of the Court

Mr. Justice HutchisoN

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The district court dismissed an unlawful detainer proceeding for want of evidence sufficient to establish title in plaintiff. In a deed of partition the property had been awarded to plaintiff for the purpose of paying certain debts against the estate of plaintiff’s deceased mother. The theory of the district judge was that title had not vested in plaintiff because she had not paid the outstanding debts against the estate. These debts became, of course, a charge upon the land. The payment thereof was not made a condition precedent to the vesting of title in plaintiff nor did her right of possession depend upon such previous payment.

The judgment appealed from must be reversed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.