Treasurer of Puerto Rico v. Banco Comercial de Puerto Rico
Treasurer of Puerto Rico v. Banco Comercial de Puerto Rico
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The appellant herein petitioned the District Court of San Juan for an order directing the receiver of the Banco Comer-cial de Puerto Rico to pay to him a certain sum of money, and as that petition was denied, he took the present appeal.
The theory of the appellant, according to the only ground urged in support of his appeal, is that he is entitled to recover from the bank the amount invested in the repairs that he, as negotiorum, gestor, made to the building, inasmuch as he made them for the benefit of the creditor bank, and that the payment for repairs which was made to the bank by the insurance company was improper.
The quasi contract of negotiorum gestio, which is recognized and regulated by our Civil Code in its sections 1789-1795, may arise where a person voluntarily assumes an agency or the management of the property of another, without authorization from the latter, and the owner who avails himself of the advantages of such management is liable for the obligations contracted for his benefit; but as in the instant case the said building did not belong to the bank but to the corporation of which the appellant was vice president, it cannot be held that the repairs made by him were for the benefit of the bank and that the latter should-pay for them, since
Regarding the claim that the insurance company improperly paid to the bank the costs of the repairs, that is a question which concerns these two entities, but such fact does not entitle the appellant to have the bank deliver to him that which, according to said appellant, the insurance company improperly paid to the bank.
The order appealed from must be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.