Osorio Ruiz v. Teachers' Ass'n of Puerto Rico
Osorio Ruiz v. Teachers' Ass'n of Puerto Rico
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a petition filed in the District Court of Mayagüez for a writ of mandamus, to compel the Teachers’ Association
The lower court relied on Piereschi v. Commissioner of Agriculture, 62 P.R.R. 109. In that case we held that after answer, the district court, in passing on a motion for transfer of a case, may consider the convenience of witnesses. But that case is not in point, as the pleadings show that there is no controversy here concerning the facts. The petition and answer reveal that the only dispute between the parties is on a question of law; namely, who is entitled to the death benefits. In a case involving only a question of law, the convenience of witnesses plays no part. The district court therefore erred in overruling the motion for transfer.
The order of the district court will be reversed and the case remanded with directions to transfer the case to the District Court of San Juan.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.