Burgos v. District Court of Puerto Rico
Burgos v. District Court of Puerto Rico
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
In the District Court of Puerto Rico, Caguas Section, Diego Burgos was charged with the offense of abandonment of minors. The corresponding trial was held on October 15, 1952, and the Court, with the consent of defendant and his attorney, postponed the pronouncement of judgment to the 27th of the same month and year.
The accused filed in the Superior Court of Puerto Rico, Caguas Part, a petition for Certiorari and contended that since judgment thus rendered is absolutely void, he should be acquitted. After the writ sought was issued and the parties were heard, it was thereafter quashed by an order rendered on April 1 of the past year, and at the same time it
Pursuant to the provisions of § 29 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1935 edition:
“After having heard the charge, if the defendant plead ‘not guilty’ the justice shall proceed as follows:
“Fourth. The justice of the peace shall then consider the evidence, and within twenty-four hours thereafter render Ms decision. The trial must be had and the decision rendered in the presence of the defendant; Provided, That the defendant may be excused from this requisite in those offenses which, by their nature do not imply mental perversity or moral depravity (mala prohibita) in said accused, when he is represented by counsel and the latter is present on both occasions. . .2 (Italics ours.)
It is an admitted fact that the accused, as well as his counsel, was in court during the trial. Here the controversy centers around two situations: the first one is that the district judge did not render judgment within 24 hours after the trial and the second that the judgment of conviction was rendered in the absence of the accused and/or his attorney.
It has been repeatedly held that the provisions previously copied from «§ 29 apply solely and exclusively to the District Court, the^ former municipal courts. People v. Lebrón, 61
Since here the accused waived any term of prescription, his contention that the District Court lacks jurisdiction to render judgment against him at the date that it did so, should not prosper. People v. Rodríguez, 76 P.R.R. 337, 341.
As to the contention that judgment of conviction was rendered in the absence of both the accused and his counsel, the statutory provision is likewise mandatory — in this case both parties admit that judgment was rendered in the. absence of the accused and his attorney. Its violation, however, should not carry with it the acquittal of the accused, as is the ease when judgment is not rendered within twenty-four hours after the trial in the absence of a waiver to that effect. This is so because once the twenty-four hour term is expired, it is imposible to revive it and to obey the statute strictly. However, rendering judgment in the absence of the accused and/or his attorney does not have the same consequences. This is an act which can be revived easily by setting a new date for the pronouncement of judgment and by rendering it in the presence of the accused and his attorney. Therefore, when judgment is rendered without defendant or his counsel, or both when necessary, being present, the only thing which is void is the judgment itself, leaving all previous proceedings in full force and effect. Cf. State Ex rel. Shetsky v. Utecht, 36 N. W. 2d 126, 6 A.L.R. 2d 988; State v. McClain, 56 S.W. 731. The only error assigned, therefore, was not committed.
The judgment will be affirmed.
The record of the District Court was not sent to us, but the judgment roll before us reveals that in the record there is a note written by hand by the district judge, which copied verbatim read thus:
“The passing of judgment is postponed to October 27, 1952. Lie. M. Igartúa waives any 'prescription term. H.R.T. October 27, 1952.” (Italics ours.)
The ease of People v. Colón, 14 P.R.R. 80, was decided before the Í.925 amendment of paragraph 4 of § 29, supra.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.