Rullán Mayol v. Secretary of the Treasury
Rullán Mayol v. Secretary of the Treasury
Opinion of the Court
JUDGMENT
The judgment appealed from, rendered by the San Juan Part of the Superior Court in above-entitled case, on February 20, 1953, is affirmed.
I attest:
Ignacio Rivera, Secretary
Concurring Opinion
concurring.
On June 23, 1952, the Secretary of the Treasury notified José Rullán Mayol of an administrative decision levying a certain property tax. Under § 2 of Act No. 1 of September 27, 1951 (Sp. Sess. Laws, p. 92), the taxpayer had 180 days to appeal from the decision to the former Tax Court of Puerto Rico. Those 180 days would expire on December 20, 1952, which fell on a Saturday. Saturday was a working day under Administrative Bulletin No. 26 of December 15, 1952, issued by the Governor of Puerto Rico to reorganize the working periods during Christmas, 1952 and during the festivities of the inauguration of the new governor-elect, designating as rest days from noon of December 24 to Thursday , December 25, and from Thursday, January 1, to Tuesday, January 6, and ordering that work be performed the whole day on Saturday, December 20 and 27, 1952. In the belief that Saturday, December 20, 1952, was a nonworking day, the taxpayer, instead of filing his appeal on that day, which was the last day of the term to appeal, filed it the following Monday, December 22, 1952. The Secretary of the Treasury moved for dismissal on the ground that the appeal was belated, and the trial court rendered judgment ruling that it was untimely filed. The taxpayer appealed from the judgment assigning as the only error the fact that the trial court refused jurisdiction on the ground that the appeal was belated.
Sections 10 and 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure of Puerto Rico of March 10, 1904, provide: 10. — “The courts of justice may be held and judicial business be transacted on any day, except as provided in the next section;” 11. — “No court can be opened, nor can any judicial business be transacted on Sunday, on the first day of January, on the fourth day of July, on Christmas or Thanksgiving day, or on a day on which the general election is held, except for the following reasons: 1. — To give, upon their request, instructions to a jury when deliberating on their verdict; 2. — To receive a verdict, or discharge a jury; 3. — For the exercise of the powers of a magistrate in a criminal action, or in a proceeding of a criminal nature; Provided, that in civil causes orders of arrest may be made and executed; writs ■of attachment, executions, injunctions and writs of prohibition may be issued and served; proceedings to recover possession of personal property may be had; and suits for obtaining any such writs and proceedings may be instituted •on any day.”
It will be seen that the Legislative Assembly of Puerto Rico understood at the outset that the executive and judicial departments should not be unified as respects the closing of their official business because of certain characteristics of
Section 9 of Act No. 88 of May 11, 1931 (Sess. Laws, p. 534), creating the Civil Service Commission of Puerto Rico, provided: “The Civil Service Commission shall promulgate rules for the administration of this Act, which rules when approved by the Governor, shall be promulgated and shall have the force and effect of law, provided they are not in conflict herewith.” Rule XLIX, promulgated on this authority and which became effective on May 11, 1942, provided: “It shall be the duty of the head of every department and of other public services of the Insular Government of Puerto Rico to require all employees, of any rank or class, in the different departments and offices, to work not less than seven and one-half hours a day, without excluding lunch time, and excluding Saturdays, Sundays, holidays, and leaves of absence granted under Rule XXXIX. However, the head of any department or other public service of the Insular Government of Puerto Rico may increase the working hours herein required for any or all employees of his office whenever in his opinion the needs of the public service in the office under his direction warrant such an increase.”
It was on the authority of that order that Saturday was made a holiday for all employees, of any rank or class, in the different departments and “other public services of the Insular Government.” Now then, were the officers and employees of the judicial branch included in the order? It is altogether clear that they were not. In the first place, § 4 (i) of Act No. 88 of May 11, 1931, expressly excluded from the Civil Service “all officers of the judicial service not otherwise included in the Unclassified Service.” This exclusion referred to “all officers appointed by the Governor
Act No. 345 of May 12, 1947 (Sess. Laws, p. 594), as amended, creating the Office of Personnel, is the first legislative attempt to unify all officers and employees of the executive and judicial branches in a central civil-service system. In the definition of “Insular Service” or “Insular Government,” § 2(4) provides that it “shall include all the offices and positions in the service of The People of Puerto Rico, as well as offices and positions in public corporations which are instrumentalities of The People of Puerto Rico, and shall include the following groups of offices or positions: (a) Service exempt, (6) Non-competitive service, (e) Competitive service.” Section 2(5) defines appointing authority as “any officer or agency with legal power to make appointments to positions in the Insular Service.” As to the former Tribunals of the Judicial District of San Juan and the Court of Tax Appeals of Puerto Rico, the appointing authority continued generally to be the same until the enactment of Act No. 432 of. May 15, 1950 (Sess. Laws, p. 1126), establishing the Organic Act of the Judiciary of Puerto Rico, § § 7, 20, and 31 of which made the following changes in the appointing authority: The Governor of Puerto Rico, by
This was the situation prevailing in 1952, when the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico was adopted and Act No. 11 of July 24, 1952 (Sp. Sess. Laws, p. 30) —“the Judiciary Act of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico” —was enacted. Harmonizing the provisions of § 8 of Act No. 345 of May 12, 1947, creating the Office of Personnel, as amended by Act No. 30 of June 8, 1948 (Sp. Sess. Laws, p. 82), Act No. 323 of May 13, 1949 (Sess. Laws, p. 972), Act No. 391 of May 11, 1950 (Sess. Laws, p. 930), Act No. 13 of March 7, 1951 (Sess. Laws, p. 30), and Act No. 12 of July 24, 1952 (Sp. Sess. Laws, p. 58), with the provisions of § 3 of Act No. 11 of July 24, 1952, enacting the “Judiciary Act of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico,” the judges, prosecuting attorneys, secretaries, marshals, and public defenders are included in the Exempt Service; the secretaries to the judges,- assistants to the secretaries, and assistants -to the marshals are in the Non-competitive Service; and “all other necessary personnel of the Court” are in the Competitive Service. The “appointing authority” for judges (§ § 12, 17, 21) is the Governor of Puerto Rico; for secretaries and deputy secretaries (§3), the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court; for marshals (§3), the Governor of Puerto Rico; for deputy marshals (§ 3), the marshals themselves ; and for “all other necessary personnel of the Court” ($ 3), the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.
The new personnel rules were promulgated on September 9, 1952, as a result of which the former Civil Service Rule XLIX, according to which Saturday was supposedly a
1. January 1 New Year's Day
.2. January 6 Three Kings’ Day
3. January 11 Eugenio M. de Hostos Birthday
•4. February 22 Washington’s Birthday
■5. March 22 Abolition Day
6. Movable Good Friday
7. April 16 José de Diego’s Birthday
8. May 30 Memorial Day
9. July 4 Independence Day
10. July 17 Luis Muñoz Rivera’s Birthday
11. July 25 Constitution Day
12. July 27 José Celso Barbosa’s Birthday
13. September (First Monday) Labor Day, Santiago Iglesias’ Birthday
*506 14. October 12 Columbus Day
15. Movable Election Day
16. November 11 Armistice Day
17. November 19 Discovery Day
18. November (Fourth Thursday) Thanksgiving Day
19. December 25 Christmas Day
Holidays coinciding on Sundays shall be observed the following day. Nothing herein provided in this Rule shall apply to those employees who, by the special nature of their services, are required to work Sundays or holidays
The new personnel rules reserve' to the Governor of Puerto Rico the power to make any day a holiday; Sunday is considered as a day of rest and Saturday is eliminated as a rest day. The distribution of work, within a weekly period of not less than 37-% hours nor greater than 48,. rests within the discretion of the appointing authority.
In order to meet plaintiff-appellant’s objection to the effect that in everything concerning working hours and holidays the regulation of the courts, after adoption of our Constitution, is wholly independent of the regulations adopted for the executive branch of the government, we are compelled to examine the question. "When the Constituent Convention of Puerto Rico was held, the Civil Service system comprised in Act No. 345 of May 12, 1947, as subsequently amended, had already been adopted. The proceedings of the Constituent Convention of Puerto Rico, p. 232, contain no parliamentary debate on the adoption of § 7 of Art. V of our Constitution. In adopting this Section, the Constituent Convention followed the report of the judicial Branch Committee, an extract of the pertinent parts of which reads as. follows: “Section 9. — The Supreme Court shall adopt rules for the administration of the courts of justice of Puerto Rico. Such rules shall be subject to the laws concerning personnelr audit and appropriation of funds, procurement, and other related laws which apply generally to all branches of the
It will be seen that the rule-making power vested in the Supreme Court by our Constitution is subject “to the laws concerning procurement, personnel, audit and appropriation of funds, and other latos which apply generally to all branches-of the government.” Our Constitution did not, therefore, recognize the traditional power of this Court to regulate,.
Under the provisions of § 387 of the Political Code of Puerto Rico of 1902 as well as under subd. 3 of Personnel Rule 8, promulgated on September 9, 1952, on the authority vested by § 7 (a) of Act No. 345 of May 12,1947, as amended, •creating the Office of Personnel, the Governor of Puerto Rico may designate any official working day as a holiday. Such •declaration shall be compulsory for the executive as well as .for the judicial branch of the Government of Puerto Rico, with the consequent interruption of the official business, except in those instances where the nature of the public .services requires that the work be continued. However, appellant’s main contention is that since Saturday was designated as a day of rest and no judicial business could therefore be transacted, the Governor of Puerto Rico was without authority on December 15, 1952, to make it a working day. We have commented at length on the previous applicable legislation in order to properly meet this argument.
True, the Governor of Puerto Rico is the appointing authority and could therefore reorganize the work week, as to certain judicial officers, under Personnel Rule 8, but it
Though the Governor of Puerto Rico may have no authority to make Saturday a working day for the judicial branch, we must also determine whether Saturday has been expressly made a nonworking day by some mandatory legal provision. Neither § 387 of the Political Code of 1902 nor $ $ 10 and 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 1904 made Saturday a nonworking day for the transaction of judicial business. It is true that the old Rule XLIX of the Civil Service Commission, which took effect on May 11, 1942, made it a nonworking day for the transaction of any public business. But it is no less true that the officers and employees of the judicial branch were never comprised in the Classified Civil Service, and continued to be governed, as to holidays, by the provisions of § 387 of the Political Code of 1902, and as to-work days, by the regulations of the courts themselves, in the light of the permissive or restrictive provisions of § § 10' and 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure of 1904. So much so that while Civil Service Rule XLIX was in force the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico promulgated on September 1, 1943, Rule 77 of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the Courts of Puerto Rico, an extract of the pertinent parts of which provides: “(a) Courts Always Open. — The courts shall be deemed always open for the purpose of filing any pleading
But even assuming that Civil Service Rule XLIX, which made Saturday a nonworking day for the transaction of official business, were applicable to the judicial branch, that rule ceased to be in force on September 9, 1952, when the new Personnel Rules became effective. Rule 8(1) of the latter provides that the basic work week for the employees in the Competitive and Noncompetitive Services shall be up to 48 hours worked on 5 or 6 days. Saturday is therefore included among the possible work days. Subdivision 3 of that rule, after designating the legal holidays, including others which by proclamation of the Governor may be made holidays, provides: “Holidays coinciding on Sundays” (set apart as a day of rest by § 28 of Act No. 345 of May 12, 1947, as amended by Act No. 23 of June 7, 1948), shall be observed the following day. Evidently, Saturday is excluded from the holidays or rest days.
The judgment appealed from should be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.