El Mundo, Inc. v. Puerto Rico Labor Relations Board
El Mundo, Inc. v. Puerto Rico Labor Relations Board
Opinion of the Court
JUDGMENT
El Mundo, Inc., has requested this Court to review a Decision of the Labor Relations Board (D-391) which ordered: (1) to cease and desist from violating in any manner whatsoever the terms of a collective bargaining agreement signed with the Puerto Rico Newspaper Guild, Local
El Mundo, Inc., challenges that Order (1) because the Labor Relations Board lacks jurisdiction to take cognizance of the matter, El Mundo being an industry in interstate commerce; (2) because the administrative remedies fixed in the collective agreement were not exhausted prior to the filing of the charge of unfair labor practice; and (3) because it was an error to conclude that El Mundo violated § 8(1) (f) of the Labor Relations Act of Puerto Rico.
Petitioner is not right in any of its three contentions. The count and the complaint charged the violation of a collective agreement as an unfair practice under our Labor Relations Act. We have already stated that the violation of a collective agreement is not sanctioned as an unfair labor practice in the federal legislation of labor-management relations. The fact that the federal legislation grants, for said violation, an action for damages — § 301, Taft-IIartley Act— and that that action for damages is within the jurisdiction of the courts, whether federal or state, does not preclude our Labor Relations Board, as an administrative agency, from taking cognizance under our Act of such a violation as an unfair practice. This question has already been clearly decided by this Court. P.R. Telephone Co. v. Labor Relations Board, ante, p. 247; Puerto Rico Telephone v. Labor Relations Board, 86 P.R.R. 362 (1962); Labor Relations Board v. I.L.A., 73 P.R.R. 568 (1952).
The evidence supports the conclusion of the Trial Examiner subscribed to by the Board to the effect that
By virtue of the foregoing, the challenges made by petitioner, El Mundo, Inc., to the aforesaid Decision and Order (D-391) of the Puerto Rico Labor Relations Board of June 9,
1965, do not lie, and consequently the petition for review is denied.
It was so decreed and ordered by the Court as witnesses the signature of the Chief Justice.
I attest:
(s) Joaquín Berríos Acting Secretary
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.