Supreme Court of Rhode Island, 1891

Mowry v. Latham

Mowry v. Latham
Supreme Court of Rhode Island · Decided August 1, 1891 · Durfee, Matteson
40 A. 236; 20 R.I. 786; 1891 R.I. LEXIS 84

Counsel

Marquis D.L. Mowry, for appellant. Stephen A. Cooke and Louis L. Angell, for appellee.

Mowry v. Latham

Opinion of the Court

The court is of the opinion that Marquis D. L. Mowry, as guardian of the person and estate of Edwin H. Mowry, next of kin of the intestate, bad an interest sufficient to entitle him to appeal, and that his appeal bond is valid.

The court do not think that the appointment of said Latham was invalid because the application therefor was made within thirty days of the intestate's decease; the appointment itself having been made more than thirty days thereafter.

(March 7, 1891.).

Addendum

We think the appellant's motion to dismiss should be denied. There is nothing in our statutes which makes it essential to the validity of an application for the appointment of an administrator on an intestate estate, that the applicant should be interested in the estate as next of kin, or as creditor of the deceased, and we are of the opinion that a grant of administration, made upon the application of a person who is neither creditor or next of kin, would be *Page 788 valid unless appealed from and reversed. We think, however, that such applications are not to be encouraged; especially where the applicant is a mere intermeddler, or where there is no need of administration, and that the court might properly in its discretion and on its own motion refuse to entertain such an application, and, of course, might on the motion of any person interested in the estate, dismiss it. The applicant here, however, can hardly be regarded as a mere intermeddler. He was an uncle of the deceased and nearest of kin to him of any one but the brother, who is non compos and is under the guardianship of the appellant, and there is no suggestion that the administration is unnecessary. It does not appear that any opposition was made to the application in the court below upon the ground on which the appellant moves now to have it dismissed, and the proceeding, after the appeal to this court, remained in this court for more than three months before this motion was made. We are of the opinion that, in view of this delay, we may properly, in the exercise of our discretion, deny the motion.

Motion denied.

Addendum

The court is of the opinion that the domicile of Van Buren Mowry, deceased, at the time of his death was in Smithfield, and, therefore, that the Probate Court of that town has jurisdiction to grant administration upon his estate.

The court is, however, further of the opinion that the appellant, Marquis D.L. Mowry, as the guardian of the estate of Edwin H. Mowry, the brother and next of kin of the deceased, is entitled to administration in place of said Edwin, who would have been entitled, if competent, and in preference to the appellee, Daniel W. Latham, a stranger nominated by a person who would have been of the next of kin, had said Edwin died before the deceased.Johnson v. Johnson, 15 R.I. 109.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.