Jones v. New American File Co.

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Jones v. New American File Co., 42 A. 509 (R.I. 1898)
21 R.I. 125; 1898 R.I. LEXIS 39
Mattesou, Stiuess, Tillinghast

Jones v. New American File Co.

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam.

(1) The court is of opinion that the amended declaration sufficiently sets out the defect in the machine.

It also sets out that the plaintiff notified the defendant of the defect and received a promise that it should be repaired, relying on which he went on with his work. We cannot say, as a matter of law, that the plaintiff under these facts would be precluded from a recovery. It is a question of fact whether he can be regarded as excused from taking the risk of the employment after such a promise. This question would depend on whether the information was given simply to.a fellow-servant or to the proper agent of the company, whether the promise was by such agent, whether reasonable time had gone by without the repair having been made, thus showing that the plaintiff was not relying on the promise, and further, whether, after knowing the danger, his own care and precautions were proportionately increased.

Reference

Full Case Name
Edwin Jones vs. New American File Co.
Cited By
1 case
Status
Published