Jastram v. McAuslan
Cases that cite this one
9 later published cases cite this decision.
- Ventures Management Co., Inc. v. Geruso (R.I. 1981)
- In re Clift's Estate (Utah 1945)
- Helwing v. Heath (Utah 1945)
- The People v. Lamothe (Ill. 1928)
- Wellman Engineering Co. v. Calderon Automation, Inc. (Ohio Ct. App. 1965)
- Adams v. Rakowski (Ill. App. Ct. 1943)
- Gottwals v. Manske (Nev. 1940)
- Tudor v. Firebaugh (Ill. 1936)
- Witmer v. District Court (Iowa 1912)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
From a decree entered in the Superior Court, denying and dismissing the complainant’s petition that the respondent trustees be adjudged in contempt for not paying to the complainant the. sum of $11,732.80, together with interest at the rate of six per cent, on the sum of $3,302.90, from March 13, 1907, to the date of satisfaction of the decree heretofore entered in this cause on April 1, 1908, the complainant has appealed to this court.
The respondents have moved to dismiss the appeal on the *391 ground that no appeal lies in such case, and, saving their rights under that motion, contend that they are not in contempt of the decree aforesaid.
The motion to dismiss the appeal must be denied. The distinction between criminal contempts and those which are civil in their nature is well settled. And it is well settled, also, that an appeal will lie in the latter class of cases. Bessette v. W. B. Conkey Co., 194 U. S. 324.
Thus, in Romeyn v. Caplis, 17 Mich. 449, 454, 455, it is said of an order adjudging a respondent in contempt for the violation of an injunction: “It has been contended before us that the order in this case was not one from which an appeal could be taken since the appellee did not claim than (that) an actual loss or injury had been produced to the party by the misconduct alleged, and did not ask for any sum to indemnify him. I think that this position cannot be sustained. . . . The order complained of was final and not merely a step in the course of proceeding contemplating further action by the court in relation to the same matter; and it belonged to that class of proceedings, which are provided to secure obedience to thje necessary processes of courts in civil cases. . The right of appeal in similar cases has long-been recognized and sanctioned elsewhere, and the necessity therefor will not be denied.”
See also City of Newport v. Newport Light Co., 92 Ky. 445, affirmed in Nienaber et al. v. Tarvin, 104 Ky. 149, 157; State v. Leftwich, 41 Minn. 42; Ballston Spa Bank v. Marine Bank of Milwaukee, 18 Wis. 515; People v. Simonson, 9 Mich. 492; Hundhausen v. U. S. Marine Fire Ins. Co. et al., 61 Tenn. 702; In re Day, 34 Wis. 638; In re Milburn, 59 Wis. 24; Baldwin v. Miles, 58 Conn. 496; State v. Horner, 16 Mo. App. 191-195, et sec.
The appeal is accordingly sustained, the decree' of the Superior Court dismissing the petition is reversed, and the cause is remanded to the Superior Court with direction to enter a decree that the respondents and each of them are adjudged to be in contempt and that they may purge themselves of that contempt by the payment of the amount named in the decree aforesaid, with interest thereon from the date of the decree, within sixty days, together with the costs of this application.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.