Morris v. Morris
Morris v. Morris
Opinion of the Court
This is a bill in equity, on facts stated in the opinion. Certified under Gen. Laws, cap.- 289, § 35, and remanded as improperly certified.
*162
The 'bill seeks neither the construction of a will or trust deed nor instructions relative to a will or trust deed and *163 therefore the cause cannot be certified to this court when it is “ready for hearing for final” decree. It cannot be certified before hearing for final decree but it may be certified after such hearing.
The exceptions to the master’s report must be determined before the cause can be heard for final decree. In a cause of this nature the Superior Court must settle the facts 'before the cause is certified. When the exceptions have been determined said court may find it necessary to send the cause back to the master with further instructions and directions to the master relative to findings.
The question has been considered recently by this court in Restino v. Tafuri, in 43 R. I. 156, decided July 6, 1920. The opinion in construing said Section 35 has removed all uncertainty as to the proper procedure thereunder. We quote from the opinion the following: “In all causes, therefore, certified under said statutory provision, a j ustice of the Superior Court, as a trier of fact, who has heard the cause for final decree, shall enter upon the record his findings upon the issues of fact, whether said cause is heard upon' oral testimony or otherwise. If the cause has been sent to a master to determine such issues, such justice must of necessity, confirm the master’s report or hear and determine all exceptions to the same before hearing for final decree and certification.”
As it is necessary to know what the facts are before attempting to apply the law to those facts it becomes necessary to return the cause, to the Superior CourCin order that-said court may determine the facts.
The cause is remanded to the Superior Court for further proceedings in accordance with this opinion.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Peter R. Morris vs. Bernard v. Morris Et Al.
- Status
- Published