Wilkie v. Walton
Wilkie v. Walton
Opinion of the Court
Curia, per
In this case, the first question which I shall consider is, whether the case was properly referred to the clerk. The Act of 1809, 7 Statutes at Large, 308, directs “that in all actions now pending, or hereafter to be brought, on any liquidated demand, wherein the defendant or defendants shall have suffered an order for
It is true these are mere suppositions, but in this way a default may be satisfied without going the whole, and saying the precise cause of action is admitted.
The danger of referring demands to the clerk, unvouched by the writing of the defendant, is strikingly illustrated by this case. Here a demand, without the slightest evidence on its face of the defendant’s liability to pay it, is referred to the clerk, who merely calculates the sum due, and thereupon, without a shadow of proof, the defendant is, by the judgment of the court, as is set out on the record, considered to be liable to pay the sum so ascertained. Such a judgment, without proof to sustain.it, cannot be supported; for the clerk had no right to assess damages against the defendant, on a paper to which his eyes would tell him he is no party. In England, the mere absence of a precedent to refer an action on a foreign judgment, was
The judgment must, therefore, be set aside as irregular. Being set aside, I think the only objection to the defendant’s appearance is removed. When the final judgment is regular, the defendant is not allowed to set it aside, and to appear and plead, on account of his attorney neglecting to appear for him; for when the judgment goes against a defendant properly served, and under no legal disability, it concludes every previous matter between the parties. But when the case is not concluded, and the defendant is able to bring himself within the rule that his failure to appear resulted from the act of God, or his attorney, then he is entitled to appear and plead. In this case the defendant has sworn he employed Mr. Eckhard to appear for him ; and although it is manifest that there was some mistake between Mr. Eckhard and him about it, yet there can be no doubt of the fact of employment; and when this is made out, the failure to appear ceases to be the act of the client; and according to the rule he must be let in, to appear and plead.
The motion to reverse the decision of the Recorder is granted. The judgment entered up on the assessment by the clerk is set aside ; so is the order for judgment by default, and the defendant is permitted to appear and plead issuably.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting. I agree with the Recorder, that the accepted bill of exchange was a liquidated demand, which, under our Act of 1809, may be referred to the clerk. Clearly it would, by the English practice, go to the master or prothonotary, as a definite contract specially declared on, the amount of which depends merely on figures. It is adjusted — ascertained with precision; that is, to meet the phraseology of an Act, liquidated. The jury could not, without the sanction of this court, give upon such a paper found or admitted, more or less than the principal and interest , and whenever default has established the liability,
That the writing does not appear to have been actually or impliedly signed by the defendant, is, I think, of no consequence ; the acceptance is alleged just as it would have been if it had been made in writing; and the contract of the defendant, expressed by the writing to which he became a party by acceptance, is specially declared on, and is of that precise character which excludes all discretion in the jury.
It has been urged that an acceptance may be partial or conditional, as well as absolute, and that when it does not appear in writing to be absolute, it cannot, in such case, be necessarily taken to be so; but the declaration alleges it to have been absolute, and the default admits it to have been so, more especially as under such an allegation there would have been no recovery at all, if the defendant, upon appearance, had shewn the acceptance to have been either partial or conditional.
This case of a mercantile contract, when legal effect and amount are precisely fixed, specially declared on, differs wholly from one of an ordinary contract in writing, which may, with equal conformity to legal requisites, be either in writing or in parol, and upon which damages, although sometimes they may be accurately estimated by general rules, are not fixed by any positive regulation ; and this case differs much more from them upon the common counts for goods sold, money had and received, account stated, <fcc. where the default admits something to be due, but the quantum depends upon the weight which the jury may give to the proof, even if a writing signed by the defendant should enter into the proof.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.