State v. Huntingdon
State v. Huntingdon
Opinion of the Court
Prior to the inquest taken in this case, by John H. Mitchell, and Gabriel M. JBoune-theau, Justices of the Peace, a plea to their jurisdiction was tendered, argued, and by them overruled. The said justices then proceeded to take the inquest, and it was against the defendant. A traverse was made to this inquest, and the proceedings of the said justices, together with the inquest, was carried
In this case, I am of opinion, that the decision of the court below should be supported; that the plea to the jurisdiction of the magistrates, and the mo. jion to quash the proceedings before them be overruled, and the present motion be rejected. The Act of Assembly of 1791, and 1799, relate only to cases of a civil nature, and where damages are to be assessed; and have no application to the powers exercised by the justices under the several British Statutes, made of force in cases of forcible entry, which have been acted upon for years in this country : Powers which, in my judgment, are highly conducive to the peace and good order of the community.
This is a motion to reverse the
The objection to their jurisdiction in this respect, in the argument of this motion, was founded on an Act of Assembly of Febuary, 1791, which declares, u That no action of trespass, trover, detinue, slan-(i der, or assault and battery or other action, arising i( merely from tort, shall be cognizable by a justices H of peace in this state.” This objection, in my opinion, is invalid, because the act of 1791, relates to civil suits only, and has no aplication to criminal proceedings.
It was not objected in argument, that the statutes which are in force on this subject, do not authorise justices of peace in this state to take inquisitions or indictments of forcible entry and detainer; but, as this question seems to be involved, I will briefly state my opinion thereon, and the reasons in support of it. My opinion is, that justices of peace have the power which the same magistrates have in England, in relation to this matter, and in virtue of the same statutes, which are all, either expressly or virtually, made of force here. An act of 1731. Pub. Laws. 127. provides for the summoning and obtaining juries of inquest on forcible entries and detainers,
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.