Dean v. Leonard
Opinion of the Court
The defendant was called on by the process to file his defence, on or before the first day °t the court. The plaintiff after the first day 0f the court, had a right to consider the defendant
.... ... in default, and dismiss his witnesses, if he had any attending, to disprove any defence he might expect the defendant to set up. . At any rate, after a decree had passed in his favour, he could not be ex- , , . „ . pected to be ready to controvert a defence aiter-wards made. To open the decree after it had passe£] ant} on ¿¡-¡e second day of court, in a case whee ' *
I shall give no opinion as to the regularity of the proceedings. The plaintiff has no^ alleged that he was surprised by letting the defendant make his defence the second day of court, and after he had obtained a decree: nor does he complain of any error in the decree. I conclude, therefore, that justice has been done. He comes then to ask the aid of this court to do injustice: to give him the benefit of a legal advantage, which he had obtained contraiy to equity and good conscience. I will lend him no assistance in such a case.
Lord Mansfield says “ a new trial ought to be,, granted to obtain real justice, and not to gratify
Justice Nares says, (i The court never granted a new trial when they clearly see that the merits have been fully and fairly tried.” 2 Morgan, 113. This case it appears to me, has been fully and fairly tried ; and I am, therefore, against granting anew trial.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.