Price v. M'Ilvain
Price v. M'Ilvain
Opinion of the Court
I am of opinion that the motion for a new trial in this case ought to be refused. It would be a most mischievous and dangerous thing to suffer verdicts to be overturned, or set aside, up. on the loose, random declarations of jurymen, after they are discharged, not on oath', to third persons, concerning the circumstances upon which they made up their verdict while they were on oath, previous to their delivering in their verdict into court. It would open such a door for tampering with weak and indiscreet men, .that it would render all verdicts insecure ; and, therefore, the law has wisely guarded against all such after declarations, and has considered them as unworthy of notice. Indeed, so cautious is the law upon this subject, that the court will not receive even the affidavits of the jurors themselves, to impeach their own verdicts, af
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Josiah Price ads. Andrew M'Ilvain
- Status
- Published