State v. Bunten
State v. Bunten
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
It would be sufficient in this case to say, that the question has already been decided in the case of the State v.-. The defendant in that case had been indicted for stealing two cows. It was abundantly evident that he had stolen one, but there was no proof against him as to the other. The jury, however, found a general verdict. The
In ordinary cases of larceny, where a person is charged with having stolen several articles, and he is proved to have stolen only some of them, and not all, a general verdict is good, because the punishment will be the same. But in this case the punishment is double, the penalty being increased in proportion to the number of animals stolen.
The motion for a new trial must be granted.
See Chev. 76; 1 Brev. 169.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- State v. Owen Bunten
- Status
- Published