Roberts v. Brown
Roberts v. Brown
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The question propounded, depends wholly on the construction of the acts of assembly creating and defining this jurisdiction, and to these we must look for its solution. The first in point of time, necessary to this case is the act of 1785. This,act points out the character of all the cases to which this jurisdiction is to be confined, including cases arising, ex contractu and limits the amount to £5-,
Subsequent to this period, several acts have been passed on this subject; but that which is at present regarded as defining and limiting the jurisdiction of, a magistrate, is the act of 1799. This provides that it “ shall extend to all matters of debt or other demand arising out of contract, and in no other case of a civil nature xvhatsoever, to §20.” (1 Brev. 476. 2 Faust, 318.) And upon looking into this act, it will be seen that no mention is made of proceedings by attachment, and the objection to extending it to this amount, is that it is expressly limited to £3 by the act of 1785; and under the rigid rule of construction applicable to limited powers cannot be extended beyond it. But if we look to the intention of the legislature, the most certain mad universally true rule, I think a different result will follow.
The clause of the act of 1785, quoted, appears to me not to have been intended to create a new and distinct jurisdiction, but to point out the mode of proceeding in the par- ' ticular case of attachment; and the limitation it contains seems to have been introduced with a view to avoid the consequences of a construction which might possibly give this power an unlimited extent without these guards about it. Again, the act of 1799, expressly gives to the magistrates jurisdiction of all matters arising ex contractu as far as §20; and provides that it shall extend to no other cases of a civil nature. And if a contrary construction was permitted to prevail they would be ousted of jurisdiction in
The motion fe therefore granted-
Reference
- Full Case Name
- John Roberts v. Joseph Brown
- Status
- Published