Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1879

Bratton v. Guy

Bratton v. Guy
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided April 28, 1879 · Haskell, Ver, Willard
12 S.C. 42; 1879 S.C. LEXIS 33

Bratton v. Guy

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Willard, C. J.

We must assume that the covenant of warranty, which is not ■set forth in terms, is in the usual form. If so, only unliquidated damages could be claimed under it, and, of course, an action of ■debt could not be maintained. Besides, it would be a mere evasion of the statute barring actions on covenant in four years. Whether the covenant of warranty might not have existed in a form that would support an action of debt, is not a question here; in the ordinary form, it certainly can have no such effect.

There, must be a new trial.

New trial granted.

Mol ver, and Haskell, A. J.’s, concurred.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.