Adams v. Turner
Adams v. Turner
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The plaintiff has appealed from a judgment sustaining exceptions to the report of the referee and dismissing the complaint. The question turns on the construction and effect of a decree of the Ordinary, made June 22d, 1860, upon a settlement of the estate of Elijah Turner, to which L. A. Turner and John Turner, his executors, and all other persons in interest, were parties. The decree is as follows: “ It appears from the foregoing statements that some of the legatees have received largely over their shares; it is necessary, therefore, that they pay to the executors the amounts so overpaid, with interest, from October 22d, 1859; when this is done, it is ordered that the executors pay to those who have not received their full shares the amounts found to be due them in the foregoing statement, with interest, from October 22d, 1859.” The Circuit judge, overruling the referee, held that this obligation of the executors to pay was, under this obligation, altogether conditional upon their receiving back the amounts thus overpaid and decreed to be restored. It appears that L. A. Turner, one of the executors bound by this decree, died shortly after it was pronounced, and that such repayments as had been made under the decree by way of restoring the amounts overpaid, were actually paid to the surviving executor, and hence the court concluded that the defendant, the executor of this deceased executor, was not liable under the terms of the decree.
The question is, whether the decree created an absolute or a conditional obligation on the part of the executors. It is clear that postponing the time of payment until a future event that was certain to occur, did not prevent the obligation from being absolute. According to the form of this decree, the time of payment was fixed when the over-payments should be refunded. We are not at liberty, however, to overlook the nature of the
It follows that the judgment of the Circuit Court must be-reversed, and the report of the referee confirmed, and the cause remanded to the Circuit Court for a judgment in accordance-with the report of the referee.
Decree reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- S. ADAMS v. C. P. TURNER
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Where executors overpay some of the legatees, and, by decree of the Ordinary, they are directed to pay balance due to the other legatees when they have collected the amounts overpaid, such decree creates an absolute obligation upon the executors, with a reasonable time allowed to call in, their over-payments.