Lancaster v. Barnwell County
Lancaster v. Barnwell County
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
In this case the plaintiff, as sheriff of Barnwell County, presented his account to the county commissioners, containing charges of one dollar for the arrest of each person named in a witness warrant issued by a trial justice in a case within the jurisdiction of the Court of General Sessions. The account also contained a charge of twenty-five cents for each entry of a warrant issued by the trial justice in cases cognizable by the Court of Sessions. The board of county commissioners disallowed all charges of the character above specified, and the plaintiff appealed from the judgment of the board of county commissioners to the Circuit Court, where the judgment appealed from was reversed; that court holding that the county commissioners erred in both respects, and that the sheriff was entitled to twenty-five cents for entry of each witness warrant, and one dollar for serving or arresting each person named in such warrant. From this judgment defendant appeals upon the several grounds set out in the record, which need not be repeated here, as the appeal raises but two questions, viz: 1st. Whether the Circuit Court erred in holding that the sheriff was entitled to one dollar for serving or arresting each person named in a witness warrant issued by a trial justice in cases cognizable by the Court of Sessions. 2d. Whether there was error in holding that the sheriff is entitled to twenty-five¡, cents for entering each witness warrant issued by a trial justice, and directed to him, in a case cognizable by the Court of Sessions.
If it should be said, that since the act of 1889 there are now no fees allowed constables in Barnwell County, and in lieu thereof they are entitled to a salary, still, that does not abolish the fees of constables in that county, for, by the express terms of section 4 of the act, those fees are still retained and required to be collected, and paid into the county treasury instead of to the constables. But even if constables’ fees in Barnwell County had been abolished outright, it would not by any means follow that this would effect any change in the law regulating the amount of costs which a sheriff of Barnwell County would be entitled to charge for serving and executing papers issued by a trial justice. That is regulated by the fees prescribed for constables under the general law of the State, and cannot be affected by any special provision made for the particular County of Barnwell; for it will be observed that section 2437, regulating the fees of sheriffs, does not provide that the sheriff should be entitled to charge, for serving and executing papers issued by a trial justice, the same fees as are allowed to constables in Barnwell County; but the provision is general — “the same fees as are allowed to constables” — which, of course, means, allowed to constables under the general law of the State, and cannot be limited, at least by mere implication, to the fees allowed constables in any particular county. If it could be, then the result would be, that if no fees were allowed to constables in Barnwell County, the sheriff of Barn-well would be entitled to no fees for serving papers issued by a trial justice, for in that view there would be no law prescrib
The judgment of this court is, that the judgment of the Circuit Court be reversed, and the judgment of the county commissioners be affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- LANCASTER v. BARNWELL COUNTY
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Costs being' purely statutory, cannot be allowed without express statutory authority, and being in the nature of penalties, statutes granting them must be strictly construed. 2. Ibid. — Sheriff Acting as Constable. — A sheriff being allowed for executing papers issued by a trial justice the same fees as are allowed constables, and the constables of the State being allowed “for serving warrant for witnesses in any criminal case upon all the persons included in said warrant, one dollar,” the sheriff of Barnwell County is entitled to receive only one dollar for executing a warrant issued by a trial justice for several witnesses for the Court of Sessions. 3. Ibid. — Ibid.—A statute that allows certain costs to a sheriff for executing papers issued by a trial justice, is not affected as to the costs of the sheriff of Barnwell County by a statute which gives to constables of that county u.salary in lieu of all costs in criminal cases, but retains the charge of costs for the benefit of the county, and also provides that for papers issued by a trial justice in cases cognizable in the Court of Sessions, and served by the sheriff, the sheriff “shall be entitled to receive therefor the fees which are now, or hereafter may be, allowed by law for such services.” 4. Ibid.— Sheriff's Entries. — A sheriff is not entitled to costs for entry in his writ book of a warrant for witnesses issued by a trial justice, there being no statutory requirement for such entry.