Morgan v. Smith
Morgan v. Smith
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
The object of this action was to enforce payment by the defendant, Beauregard Smith, of $600, which sum was alleged to be due and a charge upon certain real estate devised to the defendant under the will of Henry M. Smith, deceased. The master found against the plaintiffs; but on exceptions to the Circuit Court, - Judge Klugh, on December 10, 1898, reversed the master and decreed that two-thirds of the $600 named in the will is a charge upon the lands devised to defendant, and to be accounted for, subject to the findings of the master upon a matter recommitted to the master, viz: whether the defendant had paid out of his own funds a claim of $125 against the estate of the testator with a view to give him credit for such payment and interest against the said $600. Under this order the master took testimony and reported that the amount due defendant for payments in behalf of the testator’s estate amounted, with interest, to $264.56. On exceptions to this report, the Circuit Court, Judge Ernest Gary, overruled the same, and decreed for a sale of the premises and the payment by the defendant of the sum of $400, as a charge thereon. Within two days after the rising of the Court at which the decree of Judge Klugh was rendered, defendant’s counsel gave notice of intention to appeal therefrom ; but concluding that such decree was not final, and was reviewable after a final decree in the case, they did not proceed further, and so notified counsel for plaintiffs. Thereafter plaintiffs’ counsel procured an order from the clerk of this Court dismissing such appeal for failure to file return. *51 Within due time after the filing of the decree by Judge Gary, defendant’s counsel gave notice of appeal, exceptions to this decree and to the decree by Judge Klugh.
The decrees of the Circuit Court herein are reversed, and the complaint is dismissed, without prejudice, of course, to any right of action that may exist upon compliance with the terms of the will of Henry M. Smith, deceased.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Morgan v. Smith.
- Cited By
- 5 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. An Appeae lies from an intermediate order after filing final lecree although notice of intention to appeal therefrom has been served and such appeal dismissed by the clerk of this Court. 2. Cause oe Action — Wiels.—Under the terms of the will in question, certain devisees cannot maintain an action against another for excess in value of lands devised in remainder, as stated in the will, until the amount of the expense of defendant’s mother to him has been ascertained by three disinterested men.