Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1907

Pope v. Patterson

Pope v. Patterson
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided October 5, 1907 · No. 6682 · Woods
58 S.E. 945; 78 S.C. 334; 1907 S.C. LEXIS 216 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Mr. B.T. Rice , for appellants, cites: Trustee takes fee only for life of grantor: 25 S.C. 493 ; 16 S.C. 546 . And statute executes the use and vests the fee in remainder: 69 S.C. 290 ; 4 Rich. Eq., 485; Covar v. Cantelou , 25 S.C.; Snelling v. Lamar , 32 S.C.; Foster v. Glover , 46 S.C. Statute did not commence to run against Mrs. Sams until she was discovert and her coverture protects the right of plaintiffs: 15 S.C. 339 ; 11 S.C. 75 ; Jones v. Reeves , 6 Rich.; 15 S.C. 432 . Fee granted cannot be destroyed by later or subsequent clauses in a deed: 17 Ency., 8; 2 Blacks., 381; 33 Am. St. R., 795; 83 Va., 238 ; 28 S.E., 831 ; 13 Ency., 798; 36 S.E.R., 79; 32 S.E.R., 676; 17 S.C. 536 ; 11 Rich., 515; 59 S.C. 515 ; 2 Minor Inst., 177. Deed should specify purpose of the trust: 73 N.Y., 230 ; 2 Cruise on Real Property, sec. 32; 1 Sug. on Pow., 117, 173, 178; 33 N.Y., 107 ; 130 N.Y., 29 ; 95 N.Y., 76; 125 N.Y., 560 ; 127 N.Y., 426 ; 27 N.Y., 507; 2 Sug. on Pow., sec. 2, chap. VIII; 2 Leading Cases in Eq., Part 2. Power cannot be extended to , 25. Mr. W.A. Holman , contra, cites: Trustee had such duties to perform as required the legal estate to abide in him: 18 S.C. 189 . Statute would run against such trustee, and through him against his cestui que trust: 50 S.C. 120 ; 53 S.C. 126 . After lapse of twenty years presumption is grantor gave written instructions to convey: 1 Hill, ch. 376; 72 S.C. 320 .

Pope v. Patterson

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Woods.

This is a case of much difficulty, and the plaintiffs’ counsel has made a strong presentation of the argument against the construction of the trust deed from W. D. Duncan to H. A. Duncan, adopted by the Circuit Judge. After careful consideration, however, we have concluded to adopt the reasoning of the Circuit decree as sound and convincing.

The judgment of this Court is, that the judgment of the Circuit Court be affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.