State ex rel. Addy v. State Board of Education
State ex rel. Addy v. State Board of Education
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
This is a proceeding in the original jurisdiction of the Court, wherein the petitioner seeks to enjoin the State
“That not more than 50 per cent, of the exchangeable books used in the first, second and third grades, and not more than 50 per cent, of the exchangeable books used in the fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh grades, and not more than 50 per cent, of the exchangeable books used in the high*314 school grades as designated by the State board of education, shall be changed at any one adoption.”
The use of textbooks under the adoption of 1911 expired June 30, 1917. The State board in June, 1917, prescribed courses of study for the public schools, and adopted textbooks for use from July 1, 1917, to June 30, 1922, and contracts were entered into with publishers at the June, 1917, meeting.
The intention of the legislature is plain that the State board of education have the fundamental and inherent right and will use discretion in prescribing courses of study, in adopting textbooks, and generally in promoting the education of the citizens of the State and the interests of the public schools either in prescribing additional courses which require the adoption and purchase 'of new books, provided that under the act of 1914 they are forbid making a change of more than 50 per cent, of the exchangeable books. Fifty per cent, of exchangeable books are to be retained by them, so that the value is unimpaired and the scholar has the right to exchange it for any other book needed in the school from the list of books prescribed by the State board of education, paying the difference between the book exchanged and the book received, as provided for under the terms of the contract made between the State board of education and the publishers. Under the law the State board of education adopts certain books to be taught in the public schools, and no book can be taught in the public schools, unless adopted and prescribed by the State board of education; but the teachers of the public schools can take out of the books so adopted such books as they desire to teach, and leave out any books that they do not desire to teach — that is to say,, in the 1917 adoption a teacher can take out of that adoption any book he pleases, and any 1911 books left in the adoption of 1917 he can select if he wishes, but cannot be compelled to do so if he chooses books in the 1917'adoption that teach the same subjects as the books of the 1911 adoption. They
The injunction asked for is refused, and petition dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STATE EX REL. ADDY v. STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Schools and School Districts — Textbooks—Adoption and Change— State Board. — Civ. Code 1912, sec. 1708, as amended by Acts 1914, p. 450, empowering the State Board of Education to prescribe and enforce the use of a uniform series of textbooks, provided that it cannot, without permission of legislature, change a textbook within five years from its adoption, making it unlawful for teachers to use any book not prescribed without consent of the board, and provided that not more than 50 per cent, of the exchangeable books used shall be changed at one adoption, does not prevent the board increasing the number of courses and studies, or require the actual teaching for the five years after an adoption of 50 per cent, of the books in the prior adoption, but merely requires the preservation of the value for purpose of exchange, if not taught, of 50 per cent, of the books purchased under the prior adoption.