Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1918

Strickland v. Southern Ry. Co.

Strickland v. Southern Ry. Co.
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided December 30, 1918 · No. 10101 · Gary
97 S.E. 695; 111 S.C. 248; 1918 S.C. LEXIS 128 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Messrs. George B. Cromer and George B. Timmerman , for appellant. Mr. Cromer submits: The charge, taken as a whole, was so prolix, abstract, academic and ambiguous, as to bewilder and confuse the jury; whereas, the jury should have been aided by clear, concise and definite instruction: Constitution, art. V, sec. 25; 14 R.C.L., p. 725, sec. 1; 14 R.C.L., sec. 38, p. 770; 14 R.C.L., p. 778, sec. 46; 14 R.C.L. 757, sec. 25; R.C.L., p. 782, sec. 49; 8 Ann. Cas. 436. Messrs. W. Boyd Evans, C.M. Efird, Porter A. McMaster, Melton Sturkie, A.D. Martin, E.L. Asbill , for respondent. Mr. Evans submits: The trial Judge committed no reversible error when in his charge he used the word "mother" when he should have said "father:" 227 U.S. 59 ( 57 L.Ed., p. 417 ); 24 N.Y. 471 ; 11th Ont. App. Rep. 1; 235 U.S. 625 ( 59 L.Ed. 392 ). "Caused" and "occasioned" mean substantially the same thing. Standard Dictionary. The trial Judge clearly distinguished, in his charge, between negligence, contributory negligence and assumption of risk: 100 U.S. 213 -217 ( 25 L.Ed. 612-615 ); 135 U.S. 554 -570 ( 34 L.Ed. 235-241 ); 191 U.S. 64 -67 ( 48 L.Ed. 96-100 ); 220 U.S. 590 ( 55 L.Ed. 596 ); 228 U.S. 319 ( 57 L.Ed. 852 ); 232 U.S. 94 ; 58 L.Ed. 1070 ; 226 U.S. 162 -168; 57 L.Ed. 171-173 ; 170 U.S. 566 -672 ( 42 L.Ed. 1196-1191 ); 60 L.Ed. 1105 ; 161 U.S. 451 ( 40 L.Ed. 766 ); 196 U.S. ( 49 L.Ed. 382 ).

Strickland v. Southern Ry. Co.

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Citiee Justice Gary.

The facts are stated in the record, which together with the exceptions will be reported.

1 Exceptions numbered 1, 2, 3, 4 -and 5 assign error on the part of his Honor, the presiding Judge, in charging the jury, as set forth in the portions of the charge therein quoted.

2, 3 When the charge is considered in its entirety, it will be seen that the parts, thereof, quoted in those exceptions, were not prejudicial to the rights of the appellant. The other exceptions are too general for consideration.

Affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.