Spradley v. Georgia H. Ins. Co.
Spradley v. Georgia H. Ins. Co.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
This action is on an insurance policy. The policy covered a home and a piano. The home was situated on the property of another than the insured, and the piano was the property of another. The undisputed testimony establishes these facts. The building was erected under a verbal lease for three years. It does not appear that there was any stipulation therein permitting the insured to remove the building. The case was tried before Judge Moore, and a jury, at the April term of Court, 1918, for Aiken county. During the trial the issue of waiver as to the house arose. After all of the evidence was in the defendant made a motion for a directed verdict in its behalf. His Honor directed a verdict as to the claim for loss of piano, but refused as to claim for loss of house, but submitted to the jury on this issue the question of waiver. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of plaintiff for $700 and interest. After entry of judgment, defendant appealed, and by four exceptions alleges error in two particulars on the part of Presiding Judge Moore:
*154
There is no doubt that the plaintiff breached the condition his policy as to the ownership of the land upon which the building was situated. There is nothing in the evidence to show a waiver of this condition of policy. Among the conditions that would render the policy void unless provided for agreement in writing added to the policy is “if the interest the insured be other than” unconditional and sole ownership, or if the subject of insurance be a building on ground not owned by insured in fee simple, etc.
*155
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.